Work out what a corporate action does to your holding and whether it changes what your holding is worth.
Companies change their shares more often than most holders notice. They split them, merge them, sell new ones or buy some back. The announcements rarely say plainly whether you have gained, lost or stayed where you were. Some of these changes make no difference to what you own, while others move value from one group of shareholders to another.
A corporate action is anything a company does that changes its shares: how many there are, who holds them, or what each one is entitled to. Every corporate action gets the same test. Ask what happens to your share of the business, and to what you paid or received.
Letters about rights offers and other corporate actions arrive by post from CDP, the Central Depository, which keeps the record of the SGX shares you own. Marcus, a retail shareholder, received one offering him new shares in a company he holds. The envelope sat unopened on his desk for three weeks. By the time he read it the deadline had passed, and his holding was worth less. The business had done nothing wrong. The loss came from the company issuing new shares at a discount while Marcus did nothing with his offer.
In a split, each share becomes more than one share, and the price falls roughly in proportion. In a two-for-one split, 5,000 shares at S$1.60, worth S$8,000 (example figures), become 10,000 shares at about S$0.80, still worth S$8,000. Your share of the company does not change. A split can make shares easier to buy in board lots, the standard trading units on SGX, and sometimes draws a little extra trading, but it does not change what the business earns. A consolidation is the reverse: several shares are turned into one. Companies often use a consolidation to lift a very low share price.
Treat a split announcement as housekeeping. Adjust your records so your cost per share falls in the same proportion as the split, which means halving it in a two-for-one split.
A rights issue offers existing holders new shares in proportion to what they already own, usually below the market price. Lesson 7.2, "Rights issues, preferential offerings and TERP", in Dividend stocks and S-REITs, covers the mechanics in full. The analyst's question is what the issue costs a holder who does nothing.
To answer it, work out the theoretical ex-rights price, or TERP, the price the shares should trade at once they no longer carry the right to the new shares. Value the old shares at the market price, add the cash paid for the new shares at the issue price, and divide by the total shares after the issue. Each right, the entitlement to buy one new share at the issue price, is worth roughly TERP minus the issue price.
Larkspur is a made-up company with 300 million shares trading at S$1.60. It offers one new share for every five held, at an issue price of S$1.20. Five old shares at S$1.60 plus one new share at S$1.20 come to S$9.20 over 6 shares, about S$1.533. Each right is worth about S$1.533 - S$1.20, or about S$0.33.
Marcus holds 5,000 Larkspur shares worth S$8,000, so he receives 1,000 rights. He has three options. If he takes up the new shares, he pays S$1,200 and ends with 6,000 shares worth about S$9,200, which is his S$8,000 plus the cash he added. If he sells the rights, where they can be sold, 1,000 rights bring about S$333 and he keeps his value in a smaller stake. If he lets them lapse, meaning the deadline passes without him using or selling them, his 5,000 shares are worth about S$7,667, a loss of about S$333 (about 4.2%), and his share of the company falls by one sixth (about 16.7%).
Letting rights lapse is the one choice that reliably costs money, so open the letter when it arrives. Whether taking up the new shares is worth it depends on what the money is for, and the offer document has to explain this.
In a placement, new shares are sold to selected investors, usually institutions, often at a discount to the market price. Existing retail holders are not offered them. Placements are quick and cheap for the company, which is why they are common on SGX. SGX listing rules limit how large a general placement can be without holders' approval, and you can check the current limits in the SGX Rulebook.
To measure the effect, take the pre-issue value (existing shares times the market price), add the cash raised, and divide by the new total share count to get the value per share. Your stake dilution is the new shares divided by the total shares after the issue.
Say Larkspur places 30 million new shares, which is 10% of its existing 300 million, at S$1.44, a 10% discount to S$1.60. That raises S$43.2 million. The value before is 300 million x S$1.60 = S$480 million. The value after is S$480 million + S$43.2 million = S$523.2 million, divided by 330 million shares, or about S$1.585 per share, a fall of about 0.9%. Marcus's stake is diluted by 30 million / 330 million, about 9.1%.
A small per-share loss like this is acceptable if the cash goes into something that earns more than it cost. Placements become a slow leak when a company places shares every year or two to cover spending its own cash flow cannot fund. To spot this, compare the share count five years ago with the count now, alongside profit over the same period. A rising share count with flat profit means each share owns less of the business every year.
In a buyback, a company spends its cash buying its own shares, so each remaining holder owns a larger share of the business. Whether that helps the holders who stay depends entirely on the price paid compared with what the shares are worth. A buyback below value benefits them. A buyback above value destroys value for them and moves it to the holders who sold. Management often presents buybacks as "returning cash", and announcements rarely mention what the shares are worth, so your own estimate of value is what tells you which kind of buyback you are looking at.
To judge a buyback, estimate the value per share (Module 8 teaches you how to build this estimate) and multiply by the shares outstanding (all the shares currently in issue) to get the total value. Subtract the cash spent on the buyback and divide by the remaining shares. If the result is higher than your estimate, the holders who stayed gained, and if it is lower, they lost.
Marcus estimates Larkspur shares are worth S$2.00 each, so the company, with 300 million shares, is worth S$600 million. If Larkspur buys back 30 million shares at S$1.60, it spends S$48 million. That leaves S$552 million over 270 million shares, about S$2.04 per share, so the holders who stayed gained. If it buys the same 30 million shares at S$2.40, it spends S$72 million. That leaves S$528 million over 270 million shares, about S$1.96 per share, and value has moved from the holders who stayed to those who sold. Lesson 9.5, "Capital allocation: dividends, buybacks, acquisitions and reinvestment", in Module 9, returns to buybacks.
SGXNet, the SGX website where listed companies post their announcements, lists every corporate action announcement by company and date.
Pick one split, rights issue, placement or buyback on SGXNet from the past two years. For a holder who did nothing, work out how their share count and share of the company changed, and whether their holding's value rose, fell or stayed the same.
Junxiong-WFG Organisation is an authorised representative of AIA Financial Advisers Private Limited (Reg. No. 201715016G).