Short selling, borrow cost and what short interest tells you

Read short interest and borrow data as information about a stock, even if you never short one yourself.

Nearly everything a shareholder reads about a stock comes from someone who wants the price to climb: the company, analysts, people on forums. Short sellers are the exception. They are the one group of investors paid to find what is wrong with a company, and they put their own money behind what they find. You don't have to agree with them, but their activity shows up in public data, so you can see when they are circling a stock you own.

Selling shares you have borrowed

A short sale means selling shares you do not own. The seller borrows them, normally through a broker, from an institution that lends out its holdings, sells them at the current price, and promises to hand back the same number later. While the position is open, the seller pays a borrow fee and pays over any dividends the company declares. To close it, the seller buys the shares back and returns them to the lender. If the price has dropped, the seller keeps the difference; if it has risen, the seller pays it.

Suppose a trader borrows 100 shares and sells them at US$50 each, collecting US$5,000. At US$30, buying back costs US$3,000 and the trader keeps US$2,000 before costs. At US$80, the buyback costs US$8,000 and the trader is down US$3,000. At US$150, the loss is US$10,000, twice the US$5,000 collected at the start.

Someone who buys a share can lose at most what they paid, since a price cannot go below zero. A short seller's loss has no ceiling, because a price can keep rising. The lender can also ask for the shares back at any time, and the short seller then has to buy at a moment the lender picked.

What the borrow fee tells you

The borrow fee is the cost of borrowing the shares, given as a yearly percentage of the position's value. Large companies held by many investors have plenty of shares available to lend, so their fee is usually small, often a fraction of a percent a year. When many traders want to short one stock and few shares can be borrowed, the fee climbs, sometimes to tens of percent a year for crowded shorts.

For the trader above, a 2% fee on the US$5,000 position comes to US$100 a year. A 50% fee comes to US$2,500 a year, and at that level the price has to drop a long way, and quickly, for the trader to break even. A high fee tells you that demand to short the stock is strong and that the short sellers are confident enough to pay heavily for their position. Some brokers display borrow availability and an indicative borrow fee on their platforms, and data providers sell the same figures.

Short interest, float and days to cover

Short interest is the count of shares sold short and not yet bought back. For exchange-listed US stocks it is gathered and published twice a month. Finance websites and broker platforms show it, usually with two numbers calculated from it.

Short interest as a percentage of free float is shares short divided by free float. A company with 30 million shares short and a free float of 200 million (invented figures) has short interest of 15% of float. Most large US companies are in the low single digits on this measure, so a double-digit reading is unusual.

Days to cover is short interest divided by average daily volume. If the same company trades 3 million shares a day, 30 million divided by 3 million gives 10 days: roughly how many days of normal trading it would take for all the short sellers to buy back.

SGX stocks have thinner short-selling data, and retail platforms quote it less often. The ideas carry over, but you'll mostly be reading these numbers for US holdings.

Three usual reasons for a high reading

A high short interest figure proves nothing on its own. Use it as a signal to look into the company yourself, starting with which of three explanations fits.

The first is doubts about the accounts. Short sellers are drawn to companies where profit grows much faster than cash flow, where receivables keep building, or where acquisitions make the figures hard to compare. Some publish research reports setting out their case. Module 7, lesson 7.5, "Earnings quality: accruals, cash conversion and red-flag scores", teaches the accounting checks behind these signs.

The second is expected bad news: a product about to meet competition, a major customer likely to leave, or a debt falling due that the company may struggle to refinance.

The third is hedging. A fund that owns a competitor or a convertible bond sometimes shorts a stock to offset that risk, with no opinion on whether it will fall. Because part of the figure can come from this, short interest by itself can mislead you.

Squeezes, and a routine check on your holdings

A short squeeze begins when a heavily shorted stock rises sharply. As losses grow, some short sellers have to buy back, either because their broker makes them or because they hit their own risk limits. Their buying lifts the price further and forces more buying. In January 2021, GameStop shares rose many times over within a few weeks as retail buyers bought in and short sellers hurried to cover.

Treat a squeeze as a risk. While it lasts, the price reflects forced buying and says little about the value of the business, and it can fall as fast as it rose once that buying stops. If a heavily shorted stock you hold gets squeezed, go back over your thesis; a squeeze does not show the short sellers were wrong. Buying because a squeeze is under way is a bet on other people's forced trades, and the course does not teach it.

Marcus owns shares in a US chip designer and will probably never short anything himself. Every few weeks he looks up the stock's short interest, much as a careful driver glances at the fuel gauge of the car in front. Over a few months he sees it go from 2% to 6% of float. He doesn't sell. He opens the latest results announcement and reads it for anything a sceptic might worry about, and finds inventory has grown much faster than sales for two quarters. He decides this deserves a closer look at the next results and writes it down as something to check.

The routine he follows works on any US holding:

Find the short interest on a finance website or your broker's platform. Note short interest as a percentage of free float. Note days to cover. Where the data exists, check borrow availability and the indicative borrow fee. If short interest is high or rising, hold off acting on it and first work out the likely reason: doubts about the accounts, expected bad news, or hedging. Read the latest results for anything a sceptic might worry about, and note what to check when the next results come out.

Pick one US stock you own or follow. Look up its short interest on your broker's platform or a finance website, note the percentage of float and the days to cover, and decide what you'd check next.

Look up the short interest for one US stock you own or follow. Write down what it suggests and what you would check next.

Course

Junxiong-WFG Organisation is an authorised representative of AIA Financial Advisers Private Limited (Reg. No. 201715016G).