Log five paper trades and measure the gap between the price you saw and the price you would have paid.
A trade costs more than its commission, but the three other costs do not appear on any statement. The first is the spread, the gap between the bid (the highest price a buyer is offering) and the ask (the lowest price a seller will accept). The second is the extra you pay when your order uses up the shares at the best price, and the third is any move in the price between deciding to trade and trading.
You can measure all three without risking money. A paper trade is a trade you write down but do not send to the market. The costs come from the order book, the live list of orders waiting at each price, and you can read the order book without trading. The exercise is five paper trades from live order books, covering at least one SGX session and at least one US session, and it takes about 35 minutes in total. The finished table becomes the trade-cost tab of your workbook.
Pick five different stocks or ETFs: at least one large SGX stock or ETF, at least one small SGX stock and at least one large US stock. Assign order types so you use at least three of the four from Lesson 5.2, "Order types beyond limit and market, and when each helps": limit, market, closing-auction limit and stop-limit. A closing-auction limit joins the auction that sets the day's closing price.
Create a tab called "Trade costs" with one row per trade and these columns:
date and time stock order type side and quantity decision price bid ask depth at the best price fill price FX rate if foreign trade value in SGD cost against the midpoint in SGD and percent slippage in SGD and percent note
Add a separate column for commission, taken from your broker's fee schedule, and another for the currency conversion cost of the US trade. Lesson 2.1, "Where the FX cost hides in a US trade", in the course "Investing in US and global markets from Singapore", explains that cost.
The decision price is the price at the moment you decided to trade. Write it down before you look at the order screen. For an order placed overnight, the decision price is the previous close.
The fill price is the price the order would actually have got, and it depends on the order type. For a buy limit at the ask, it is the ask. For a market order, it is the average of the price levels it walked through. Walking the book happens when the best price level does not hold enough shares, so a market order fills through the next levels in turn. For an auction order that would have matched, the fill price is the official closing price.
Cost against the midpoint is (fill price minus the midpoint of bid and ask) x quantity, in SGD. It measures what the spread and any market impact cost at the moment of the trade.
Slippage is (fill price minus decision price) x quantity, in SGD. It adds whatever the price did between the decision and the fill, so the two measures can tell different stories about the same trades. Slippage is negative when the price moves in your favour after you decide. When nothing moves between decision and fill, slippage equals cost against the midpoint. A gap at the open creates slippage that has nothing to do with the spread.
Show both measures in SGD and as a percent of trade value.
Enter Marcus's trades first and check that your formulas reproduce his results. He chose an STI ETF, a local bank, Larkspur Precision (a small SGX stock), an S-REIT and a US chip designer. He used limit orders for the STI ETF, the bank and the US stock. He sent a limit order into the SGX closing auction for the S-REIT, and used a market order for Larkspur to see the cost of walking the book.
He bought 1,300 units of the STI ETF with a limit at the ask. The decision price was S$3.80 (an example figure), the bid S$3.79 and the ask S$3.80, so the fill was S$3.80 and the trade value S$4,940. Cost against the midpoint was S$6.50, about 0.13%.
He bought 100 bank shares with a limit at the ask, having set his decision price of S$32.05 earlier that morning. When he traded, the bid was S$31.99 and the ask S$32.00, so the fill was S$32.00 and the trade value S$3,200. Cost against the midpoint was S$0.50, about 0.02%. The price had fallen since his decision, so slippage was negative S$5.
He bought 5,000 Larkspur shares at market. The decision price was S$1.60, the bid S$1.59 and the ask S$1.61, with only 4,000 shares at the ask. The order filled 4,000 at S$1.61 and 1,000 at S$1.62, so the fill averages about S$1.612 and the trade value was S$8,060. Cost against the midpoint was S$60, about 0.74%, and slippage was also S$60.
He sent 2,000 S-REIT units with a limit of S$2.01 into the closing auction. At the decision the bid was S$1.99, the ask S$2.01 and the midpoint S$2.00. The auction matched at S$2.00, for a trade value of S$4,000, so cost against the midpoint was nothing.
He bought 20 shares of the US chip designer with a limit at the ask, placed after the US open. His decision price was the previous close, US$149.50. After the open the bid was US$149.98 and the ask US$150.02, so the fill was US$150.02. At S$1.25 per US dollar, the trade value was about S$3,750.50. Cost against the midpoint was about S$0.50, and slippage was S$13, about 0.35%.
Total cost against the midpoint came to S$67.50, almost 90% of it from Larkspur.
Read down the rows and ask why each cheap trade was cheap and each expensive one was not. Marcus found that large stocks and ETFs cost almost nothing with a limit at the ask. The market order in a thin stock cost more than all the others combined. The auction got the REIT the midpoint. For the US stock, the stale decision price cost more than the spread.
His rule has three parts. Every order is a limit order. Where the order is larger than the shares at the best price, or the spread is above 0.5%, he uses the closing auction or splits the order over several days. He sets US limits after the open from the live quote.
Record your own five trades the same way: decision price first, then bid, ask and depth at the best price from the order book, then the fill price from the rules above. Calculate both measures in SGD and percent, and total each one in SGD. Use the note column to explain why each trade was cheap or expensive, and write one rule of no more than three sentences under the table.
You're finished when the tab has five rows, five different stocks, at least three order types, every column filled, two cost totals in SGD and one rule of no more than three sentences. If all five trades look free, check the fill prices. A buy limit below the ask would not have filled, so it cannot count as a cheap trade.
Now open your broker's screens, record five paper trades of your own, and write your rule underneath.
Set up a trade-cost tab for five paper trades. Then write one line on how you will place orders from now on.
Junxiong-WFG Organisation is an authorised representative of AIA Financial Advisers Private Limited (Reg. No. 201715016G).