Read an auditor's report and pick out the opinion, any emphasis paragraphs and any doubt about going concern.
Pick a company you hold or are researching, download its most recent annual report, and find the auditor's report, which usually sits just before the financial statements. It is one of the shortest sections in the document and takes about five minutes to read. Most investors skip it, even though it is the only part of the annual report written by an outsider who has a legal duty to the shareholders.
Hyflux shows what can be missed. When the company went to court in 2018 to seek protection from its creditors, thousands of retail investors in Singapore owned its shares or its perpetual securities, and most of them saw the collapse as sudden. Anyone who had read its annual reports closely would have seen debt climbing year after year while operating cash flow stayed weak.
The report starts with the auditor's opinion. This states whether the financial statements give a true and fair view, or present fairly, the company's position under whichever accounting standards it follows.
Most reports carry an unmodified opinion, which is also called a clean or unqualified opinion. It means the auditor judged the accounts to be fairly presented in all material respects. It does not tell you whether the business is sound, whether the strategy is working or whether the share price makes sense. A company that is losing money, carrying too much debt and heading for trouble can still receive a clean opinion, as long as its accounts give an accurate picture of that troubled position. The auditor confirms that the figures are honest. Deciding whether they are good figures is up to you as the investor.
Modified opinions are rare, and they come in three kinds:
Qualified opinion: the accounts are fair apart from one specific matter. Adverse opinion: the accounts are not fair. Disclaimer of opinion: the auditor could not gather enough evidence to reach any view.
Any of the three is serious. If you see one, find out what caused it before you hold the shares for another day. SGX requires listed companies to announce a modified opinion promptly, so you will usually find the same news on SGXNet.
Auditing standards changed in the 2010s. Since then, auditors of companies listed in Singapore, like auditors in many other markets, have included a section headed key audit matters. In American reports the same section is called critical audit matters. The items in it are usually the parts of the accounts that rely most on estimates. Typical examples are goodwill and other assets tested for impairment, investment property valuations, inventory valuation, revenue recognised on long contracts, and provisions for legal claims. For each item the auditor explains why it mattered and how they tested it.
A key audit matter is not a warning in itself. Use the section to find the softest numbers in the accounts. Go through each matter and write down three things: why the auditor focused on it, what work they did, and which figure in the accounts it relates to. When you build a financial model in Module 7, these are the figures most likely to shift if management changes its assumptions.
Marcus, the example investor who follows the course, is studying Larkspur, an invented company with invented figures. In Lesson 6.2 he spotted that Larkspur's coatings business had a thin margin. The auditor's report is on page 88 of Larkspur's annual report, and it names two key audit matters. The first covers the valuation of S$70 million of inventory in parts and materials. Some of this stock was built for particular customers' machines and would be difficult to sell to anyone else if those orders were cancelled. The second covers the impairment test on S$30 million of goodwill from Larkspur's purchase of the coatings business, a test that depended on management's forecast of a recovery in coatings profits. Marcus sees that the auditor examined the same coatings question he had already picked out.
Two more paragraphs can appear under the opinion without changing it, and you should read both carefully when they appear.
An emphasis of matter paragraph points to something the accounts already disclose that the auditor believes readers must understand, for example a major lawsuit or an asset sale with an uncertain outcome. The opinion stays clean in this case. Turn to the page the paragraph refers to and read what is on it.
A section titled material uncertainty related to going concern is more serious. It appears when events or conditions cast significant doubt on whether the company can continue, for example debts falling due with no confirmed refinancing. The accounts are still prepared on the basis that the business will carry on, but the auditor is warning readers that it might not. Some companies with going-concern doubts recover and many do not, and when a company fails its shareholders are paid last. If the auditor of a stock you own includes a going-concern section, read the note it refers to on the same day.
You can check two warning signs outside the report by searching the company's announcements on SGXNet: changes of auditor and late reports.
Companies change auditors for ordinary reasons, such as a tender to cut fees, a rotation rule, or growing too large for a small audit firm. A change can also follow a disagreement over accounting. The announcement of the change should give the reason, and the outgoing auditor is usually asked to confirm whether there is anything shareholders should know. Read the company's stated reason and the outgoing auditor's confirmation together.
A late annual report or a delayed results announcement is a less obvious warning sign. A company that cannot close its books on time often has problems, and the report that eventually comes out tends to show what they are. If you find an extension request on SGXNet, record it in your log along with the reason the company gave.
Marcus runs the same search for Larkspur. He finds that the company has used the same audit firm for the past eight years and has filed every report on time, which is the result you hope to see. That does not make Larkspur a good investment, but it does remove one class of problem from his checks.
For the activity, open the auditor's report in your chosen company's latest annual report, note the opinion, and list each key audit matter with the figure in the accounts it relates to.
Read your chosen company's auditor's report and list each key audit matter with the figure it relates to.
Junxiong-WFG Organisation is an authorised representative of AIA Financial Advisers Private Limited (Reg. No. 201715016G).