Reconcile a company's adjusted profit to its reported profit and judge each adjustment.
Marcus has been reading company headlines like Larkspur's for years and has never asked what was removed to produce them. Larkspur's latest announcement says core net profit rose 38% to S$47 million (Larkspur and every figure for it are invented examples). You can test a number like that by rebuilding it yourself from the company's own reconciliation table.
Net profit is the figure accounting standards define. Alongside it, many companies publish adjusted figures, also called non-GAAP measures, which take net profit and strip certain items out. GAAP means generally accepted accounting principles, the US accounting rules. The labels vary: core profit, underlying earnings, adjusted EBITDA (earnings before interest, tax, depreciation and amortisation), non-GAAP earnings per share. You test an SGX company's core profit with exactly the same method you'd use on a US company's non-GAAP earnings.
Rules from the US Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC), the US market regulator, set two conditions. The GAAP figure must appear with prominence at least equal to any non-GAAP measure, and each non-GAAP measure must be reconciled back to the GAAP figure. Even so, the reported number can sit some distance from the headline, and the list of exclusions is often tucked into a footnote. Larkspur's income statement turns up three pages after its headline and shows net profit of S$48 million. A footnote explains that core profit leaves out a gain on selling a property, share-based pay and restructuring costs.
The usual exclusions are restructuring costs, impairments, gains or losses on asset sales, acquisition costs, amortisation of intangible assets acquired in deals, and share-based pay. An impairment writes down an asset whose value on the books is now judged too high. Amortisation spreads the cost of an intangible asset, such as a brand or customer list bought in a deal, over several years.
Management's case is that these items are one-off or non-cash and blur the picture of how the business is running. In some instances that case holds up. Selling a property produces a one-off gain, so keeping it in profit flatters a single year. Taking it out leaves a better base to forecast from. In many other instances the case does not hold, so you need a test that separates the two.
The test is one question asked of every adjustment: does this happen every year? An item that turns up every year is a recurring charge, and it is part of what it costs to run the business regardless of the label the company gives it.
Restructuring is where this question catches most companies. A restructuring that happens once in a decade is a fair one-off. When restructuring appears every year, the company is paying continuously to reshape itself. An investor who removes it each year is treating a real, ongoing cost as if it were absent. Marcus goes back through three years of Larkspur announcements and finds restructuring charges in each of them, of S$3 million, S$2 million and S$3 million, all attributed to "efficiency initiatives". On that evidence Marcus adds restructuring back into Larkspur's profit.
Impairments get the same question. Serial acquirers, companies that grow by buying one business after another, often book them year after year as earlier deals keep falling short of expectations. An impairment that returns that often is a cost of the way the company chooses to grow.
Share-based pay means the cost of the shares and options a company grants its employees. It's often excluded on the grounds that no cash goes out, but the payment is still made in something shareholders own. When a company issues new shares to employees, every existing share now represents a smaller portion of the company, which is called dilution. When the company buys back shares to cancel out that dilution, the buyback uses real cash. Shareholders carry the cost through one route or the other. Warren Buffett has argued this for decades in Berkshire Hathaway's shareholder letters, asking, in effect, what share-based pay could be if it is not an expense.
The amount ranges widely. Some companies grant very little, while many US technology companies grant far more. Marcus also owns shares in a US chip designer (an invented example) with reported net profit of US$800 million and adjusted net profit of US$1,170 million. Its reconciliation adds back US$300 million of share-based pay, US$120 million of amortisation on acquired intangibles and US$40 million of restructuring. It then takes off US$90 million for the tax effect of those items, so 800 + 300 + 120 + 40 - 90 = 1,170. Share-based pay accounts for most of the difference. After Marcus puts share-based pay and restructuring back, the honest profit sits much nearer the reported US$800 million than the US$1,170 million headline.
A reconciliation table sets out, one line at a time, how the company moves from reported profit to adjusted profit. Start from that table rather than constructing a reconciliation of your own. For US companies it appears in the results press release and often in the 10-K, the annual report US companies file with the SEC. SGX companies usually put it in the results announcement or the operating review.
Set three years next to each other, running from reported profit down to adjusted profit, with a separate line for every adjustment. Beside each line, write fair or not fair and a one-line reason. For Larkspur's most recent year, Marcus's working looks like this:
Reported net profit: S$48 million Gain on property sale removed: minus S$6 million (fair, because it will not recur) Share-based pay added back: plus S$2 million (not fair, because it recurs and costs shareholders) Restructuring added back: plus S$3 million (not fair, because it appears in all three years) Core net profit: S$47 million
Your underlying profit uses only the adjustments you marked fair. For Larkspur that leaves S$48 million minus S$6 million, or S$42 million. Dividing by the 300 million shares outstanding gives 14 cents a share. Set that beside management's number: Marcus's underlying profit is S$5 million, about 11%, below the S$47 million core profit.
Then look at the direction the adjustments take over the three years. Honest adjustments run both ways, with one-off gains removed as readily as one-off losses. If every adjustment lifts adjusted profit above reported profit in every year, read that as management picking adjustments that make the results look better. In Larkspur's case, stripping out the property gain is a point in the company's favour, while the restructuring charge it removes every year counts against it.
The figure you carry into your forecast should be your own underlying profit. Building a forecast on a core profit that leaves out recurring costs takes out of the model a cost the business will keep paying. Marcus enters S$42 million in the module 7 model, and your own underlying figure belongs in yours.
Reconcile your chosen company's adjusted profit to reported profit for three years. Mark each adjustment as fair or not, with a one-line reason.
Junxiong-WFG Organisation is an authorised representative of AIA Financial Advisers Private Limited (Reg. No. 201715016G).