Cash flow statement and free cash flow

You will be able to calculate free cash flow and explain why it is harder to dress up than profit.

A company can report a profit every year and still keep raising money from its shareholders. The profit says the company makes money. The repeated fundraising says it does not keep any. You can see this contradiction in the cash flow statement, and free cash flow is the number that settles it.

Rebuilding operating cash flow from net profit

In Lesson 7.1, "How the three statements tie together", you traced Larkspur's operating cash flow from its net profit. Every company's operating cash flow follows the same logic: start from net profit and adjust.

First, add back non-cash expenses, mainly depreciation. Next, remove gains that do not belong in operations, such as a gain on selling a property, because the cash from that sale appears under investing. Then adjust for working capital: subtract increases in receivables and inventory, and add increases in payables.

Larkspur's figures are invented examples, in S$ millions. It reported net profit of 48. Add back 24 of depreciation, remove the 6 gain on the property sale, then apply working capital adjustments of minus 5, plus 2 and plus 3. That gives 48 + 24 - 6 - 5 + 2 + 3 = 66, so operating cash flow is 66.

Operating cash flow is profit corrected for timing and for non-cash items. Over a long period, a healthy business's operating cash flow and profit should be broadly in line. For capital-heavy firms, depreciation lifts operating cash flow above profit.

Taking off capital spending

The company cannot hand out its operating cash flow. It has to maintain and replace machines as they wear out, and buy more if it is growing. Subtract that capital spending and you have free cash flow: the cash available, before any dividends, to repay debt, pay shareholders, build up cash or buy other businesses. It is measured before dividends because a dividend is one of the choices free cash flow pays for, and is not a cost of running the business.

Larkspur's capital spending in FY5 was 34, so its free cash flow was 66 minus 34 = 32.

Some analysts exclude proceeds from asset sales from free cash flow, because a property can only be sold once. Others include them. The Larkspur figures exclude them. Whichever you choose, write the choice down and apply it every year.

Adjusting for leases under IFRS 16

Under IFRS 16, leases moved onto the balance sheet and lease payments are split. Repayment of lease principal goes in financing cash flow. The interest part goes in operating or financing cash flow, depending on the company's policy. Before IFRS 16, the whole lease payment was treated as rent, an operating cost.

As a result, operating cash flow, and free cash flow calculated the usual way, look better than before for exactly the same business. A company with heavy leases can show a big jump in free cash flow when the only change is where the payments are recorded.

To correct for this, find the lease principal repayments in the financing section and calculate free cash flow both ways. Free cash flow before leases is operating cash flow minus capital spending; free cash flow after leases also subtracts lease principal repaid. For retailers, airlines or companies that lease all their premises, lease payments can be most of the free cash flow. When comparing companies, use the same version for all of them. The after-leases figure is closer to the cash an owner could actually take out.

Larkspur repaid 4 of lease principal in FY5, so its free cash flow after leases was 32 minus 4 = 28.

Comparing free cash flow with profit over five to ten years

A gap between free cash flow and profit in a single year is not alarming in itself. Larkspur's free cash flow after leases of 28 was about two thirds of its underlying profit of 42, against reported net profit of 48. In FY5 it was growing again, rebuilding working capital, and spending more on equipment than its depreciation, which is normal for a business adding capacity.

What matters is what happens over five or ten years. A business whose free cash flow runs persistently far below profit is either investing heavily for growth that should show up later, or reporting profit that is not turning into cash. The first case is fine if the growth arrives. The second is the pattern behind many accounting problems.

Marcus has a colleague who owns shares in a small SGX-listed company, an invented example. It reported a profit every year for a decade and raised money from shareholders four times in that decade. Its total profits over the ten years were far more than its free cash flow, which was negative in most years. Receivables that grew every year, and money from shareholders, filled the gap. The company fitted the "profit not turning into cash" pattern: its profit was real in an accounting sense, but shareholders kept paying for it.

Profit depends on many estimates, and each gives management room to choose: when revenue counts, how fast assets depreciate, how much inventory is worth, whether goodwill is impaired. Cash depends on fewer choices, since money either arrived in the bank account or it did not. Free cash flow can still be massaged at the edges by delaying payments to suppliers at year end, selling receivables to a bank, or classifying spending as investing rather than operating. These tricks reverse within a year or two and show up in the working capital days you learned to track in Lesson 7.3. Lesson 7.5, "Earnings quality: accruals, cash conversion and red-flag scores", gives the tests for profit that is not turning into cash.

For the activity, calculate free cash flow for five years of your company's accounts, with and without lease payments, and set each year beside its net profit.

Work out free cash flow for five years, once with lease payments and once without, and set it beside net profit.

Course

Junxiong-WFG Organisation is an authorised representative of AIA Financial Advisers Private Limited (Reg. No. 201715016G).