You will be able to score earnings quality and use known screening models to pick out accounts that need a closer read.
Most accounting problems that wreck a share price were visible in the published accounts for a year or more before the blow-up. The early signs are usually ordinary: profit rising while cash does not, receivables growing faster than sales, and assets on the balance sheet that nobody can explain. The analysts who caught these problems early were not smarter than everyone else. They ran a few simple tests every year on every company they followed, and they paid attention when a test failed.
All the worked figures below use Larkspur, an invented company, for FY5, in S$ millions.
Cash conversion is operating cash flow divided by net profit. Larkspur had operating cash flow of 66 and net profit of 48, so its cash conversion is 66 / 48 = about 138%. A company with heavy depreciation normally has conversion above 100%, because depreciation reduces profit but not cash.
Some analysts use free cash flow instead of operating cash flow, which gives a tougher figure. Larkspur's free cash flow was 32, so its free cash flow conversion is 32 / 48 = about 67%.
One year of cash conversion says little. Work it out for five years and look at the pattern, comparing each year against the company's usual level and against 100%, allowing for depreciation. The warning sign is conversion persistently well below its usual level, or below 100% when depreciation should lift it above 100%. That means profit is being booked that is not arriving as cash. The usual causes are receivables and inventory growing faster than sales, or income recognised before it is received, so check the receivables and inventory figures and the revenue recognition policy first.
Accruals are accounting entries that make profit differ from cash: revenue booked but not collected, costs deferred, assets revalued. Some accrual is unavoidable and honest. A lot of it is a warning sign, because accruals are where management's estimates live.
The accruals ratio measures how much of profit comes from accruals rather than cash. One simple version subtracts operating cash flow from net profit and divides the result by average total assets. For Larkspur, 48 minus 66 is minus 18. Total assets were 389 at the start of the year and 410 at the end, an average of about 399.5. The ratio is minus 18 / 399.5 = about minus 4.5%.
A negative ratio means cash exceeded profit, which is reassuring. A high positive ratio, where profit runs well ahead of cash relative to the size of the company, has been linked in academic research to weaker future earnings and returns, though the effect varies by market and period. If the ratio is positive and rising, reread the notes on revenue and working capital.
Messod Beneish, an accounting professor, published the Beneish M-score model in 1999. It screens for signs a company has manipulated its earnings by combining eight ratios, each comparing this year with last year, into one score:
days sales in receivables index gross margin index asset quality index sales growth index depreciation index selling and administrative expenses index an index of debt to assets total accruals to total assets
These ratios capture patterns Beneish found in companies later caught manipulating: receivables growing faster than sales, margins slipping, costs being capitalised as assets, fast growth creating pressure to keep it up, depreciation slowing, and profit running ahead of cash. Higher M-scores look more like the manipulators in his sample.
You do not need to compute all eight to use the idea, and many data providers and screening tools calculate the full score for you. The first ratio is easy to do yourself. The days sales in receivables index is this year's receivables-to-revenue ratio divided by last year's. In FY5 Larkspur had receivables of 80 on revenue of 400, which is 20%. In FY4 it had receivables of 75 on revenue of 360, about 20.8%. The index is 20% / 20.8% = 0.96. Above 1 would mean receivables grew faster than sales. Below 1, as here, means receivables grew more slowly than sales, the opposite of a warning.
Edward Altman, a finance professor, published the Altman Z-score in 1968 to estimate the risk that a company will fall into financial distress. The original was built from US listed manufacturing companies and weights five ratios.
The first ratio uses working capital, which Altman defines as current assets minus current liabilities. This is wider than the working capital measure used for modelling in lesson 7.3. Larkspur's current assets are 210: cash of 60, receivables of 80 and inventory of 70. Its current liabilities are 59: payables of 45 plus the parts of debt and leases due within a year. Working capital is 210 minus 59 = 151.
Each of the five terms is a ratio multiplied by its weight. With Larkspur's total assets of 410:
Working capital of 151 divided by total assets, times 1.2, gives about 0.44. Retained earnings of 185 divided by total assets, times 1.4, gives about 0.63. Operating profit of 56 divided by total assets, times 3.3, gives about 0.45. Market value of equity of 480, at S$1.60 a share, divided by total liabilities of 125, times 0.6, gives about 2.30. Sales of 400 divided by total assets, times 1.0, gives about 0.98.
Add the five terms and Larkspur's Z-score is about 4.8. In Altman's original work, a score above about 2.99 is in the safe zone, below about 1.81 is in the distress zone, and anything between is a grey area. Larkspur is comfortably in the safe zone, mostly because of its low debt and a market value well above its liabilities.
Both the M-score and the Z-score were built on particular samples of US companies decades ago. Neither suits banks or insurers, whose balance sheets work differently. Both produce false alarms, flagging fast-growing honest companies, and both miss well-hidden frauds. Use a score to decide where to look harder. It does not tell you what the answer is.
Run all of these tests every year on every company you follow, and treat a failed test as a reason to look harder rather than a verdict. Several failing together carry more weight. Falling cash conversion, a rising accruals ratio and a receivables index above 1 for two years running give you three separate reasons to reread the revenue note and the auditor's report before investing anything.
For the activity, calculate cash conversion, the accruals ratio and the Altman Z-score for your company for each of the last three years.
Work out cash conversion, the accruals ratio and the Altman Z-score for your company for the last three years.
Junxiong-WFG Organisation is an authorised representative of AIA Financial Advisers Private Limited (Reg. No. 201715016G).