You will be able to estimate a cost of equity and a weighted average cost of capital for your company.
Marcus, an analyst, is putting together a valuation model for Larkspur, a small Singapore company and cyclical supplier whose shares change hands only now and then. His model has reached the point where he must choose a discount rate, and few inputs in the model shift the final value as much as this one does.
Lesson 8.1, "What a DCF says: value as cash flows discounted for time and risk", showed how wide the gap can be. Two analysts took one Larkspur cash flow forecast and discounted it at 8% and at 10% (example figures, like every other Larkspur rate and amount). The first got roughly S$2.11 a share and the second S$1.56. Both could be acting honestly. Analysts often pick different rates for the same forecast, so what you should check is whether each input is backed by a named source and the date it was taken.
For a DCF (a discounted cash flow valuation), the rate to build is the weighted average cost of capital (WACC). It mixes the cost of equity and the cost of debt in proportion to how much of each the company relies on, with both amounts taken at market values.
Shareholders bear more risk than anyone else funding the company, so they ask for the highest return, and that required return is the cost of equity. Most analysts estimate it with the capital asset pricing model (CAPM):
cost of equity = risk-free rate + beta x equity risk premium
Start with the risk-free rate, which is the yield on a government bond issued in the currency of the cash flows. Singapore dollar cash flows call for a Singapore Government Securities (SGS) yield, normally on the ten-year bond, since a long bond fits cash flows that stretch far into the future. MAS publishes the yields on its website. Stick with the long-term yield even in a year when short rates sit above or below it, because the DCF is valuing decades of cash. Swapping in a short-term government yield is a common mistake. For Larkspur's Singapore dollar cash flows, Marcus sets the risk-free rate at 3%.
Beta tells you how strongly a stock tends to move when the market moves. You worked one out in Lesson 2.4, "Beta, correlation and why diversification shrinks in a crisis". Larkspur's own price history won't give a reliable figure, because a thinly traded share is priced too rarely to reveal how sensitive it really is. The usual workaround is to average the betas of comparable peer companies, for instance five peers measured on five years of monthly returns. Cyclical suppliers swing more than the market, so a beta above 1 makes sense for Larkspur, and Marcus settles on 1.25.
The third input, the equity risk premium, is the additional return investors want for owning shares in place of government bonds. It can't be observed directly. Some estimates are drawn from history, others are implied by today's prices, and the answers differ from one source to another. Pick a single named source and note down which one it was. A widely used one is Aswath Damodaran of New York University, who publishes estimates on his website, and Marcus uses an equity risk premium of 5.5% in his model.
With all three in place, his cost of equity is 3% + 1.25 x 5.5% = 9.875%, or about 9.9%.
The cost of debt is the rate the company would be charged if it borrowed today. Loans signed years ago at older rates tell you little about that. When a company has listed bonds, their yield is the best evidence. Larkspur has none and borrows through leases and floating bank loans, whose interest rate moves with market rates. In that situation you can either read the current floating loan rate from the borrowings note in the accounts, or take the risk-free rate and add the margin that similar borrowers usually pay.
Interest is usually tax deductible, so the cost to the company is lower than the rate the bank quotes:
after-tax cost of debt = pre-tax rate x (1 - tax rate)
Marcus works with a 5% pre-tax rate and an assumed 17% tax rate (check the current corporate tax rate on the IRAS website), so his after-tax cost of debt is 5% x 0.83, which comes to about 4.15%.
You weight each source of funding by its market value. Investors buy in or sell out at current prices, so the return they require relates to those prices rather than to the figures on the balance sheet.
To get the market value of equity, multiply the share price by the number of shares. Larkspur has 300 million shares priced at S$1.60, which makes S$480 million. Debt is simpler: its book value, the amount shown in the accounts, is normally near enough to market value, unless the company is in financial difficulty. Include lease liabilities as debt, as in Lesson 8.1. Larkspur owes S$60 million in bank loans plus S$20 million in lease liabilities, S$80 million of debt in all, so total capital comes to S$560 million.
That puts equity at about 85.7% of capital and debt at about 14.3%:
WACC = 85.7% x 9.9% + 14.3% x 4.15% = about 9.1%
In the model Marcus enters 9%, and lets the sensitivity table in Lesson 8.6 show what happens across the range on either side of it.
A frequent slip is weighting equity at book value. Larkspur's balance sheet shows equity of S$285 million, well below the S$480 million market figure. Had Marcus used it, his WACC would have dropped to about 8.6% and the value per share would have gone up. Whenever book equity is smaller than market equity and you use it, your answer looks better than it should, since it pulls WACC down and pushes value up.
Larkspur depends heavily on a few customers, and Marcus is tempted to add two points to the discount rate to allow for that. Avoid adding a premium to the rate for each concern you have, because extra points in the rate leave the risk out of sight inside one number. Model customer concentration and other specific risks in the cash flow scenarios in Lesson 8.6, where a reader can see exactly what was assumed.
None of these inputs stays fixed. SGS yields change every day, betas drift over time, and equity risk premium estimates are revised. If you attach no dates to a WACC, nobody else can check it and you can't bring it up to date later. In the Inputs tab, put the value, its source and the date next to each of the following:
risk-free rate beta equity risk premium pre-tax cost of debt tax rate share price number of shares borrowings lease liabilities
When you do this for real, look up current values and write down the date you found each one.
Calculate a WACC for your company and write the source and date next to every input.
Junxiong-WFG Organisation is an authorised representative of AIA Financial Advisers Private Limited (Reg. No. 201715016G).