The terminal value problem and why it dominates the answer

You will be able to calculate a terminal value two ways and check that it is reasonable.

Terminal value is the value, at the end of your forecast, of every cash flow the business produces after it. You calculate it once, discount it back to today like any other cash flow, and you should expect it to make up most of the company's enterprise value.

Why one figure outweighs five years of forecast

Marcus, an analyst, spent an evening on a five-year forecast for Larkspur, a mature precision engineer that supplies a cyclical industry. He adjusted growth, margins and working capital until each year felt right. The forecast runs to FY10. When he added the terminal value, the five forecast years came to only about a quarter of total value. The other three quarters came from one formula covering every year after FY10.

That result is normal. A business does not stop at the end of year five, and terminal value captures everything after it in a single figure. For faster-growing companies, whose cash flows are small now and large later, its share of enterprise value is often even higher. It is easy to treat terminal value as a detail added at the end, but it is the largest single assumption in the model and deserves as much care as the forecast itself.

All Larkspur figures below are invented examples, in S$ millions unless stated. Marcus uses a discount rate of 9%. Free cash flow to the firm over the five forecast years is about 32.4, 35.4, 38.3, 41.0 and 43.5, and the present value of those five years is about 146.5.

Calculating terminal value with the growth method

The growth method assumes free cash flow grows at a constant rate for ever after the forecast. The value at the end of year five is next year's cash flow divided by (discount rate - growth rate).

Start with the final forecast year's free cash flow, which for Larkspur in FY10 is about 43.5. Grow it one year at the long-term growth rate. Marcus chose 2%, which gives about 44.4 for FY11. Divide by the discount rate minus the growth rate, 9% - 2% = 7%, for a terminal value of about 44.4 / 7% = about 634 at the end of FY10. Discounted back to today, that is about 412. Add the present value of the forecast years and enterprise value is about 558.6 (146.5 + 412). Terminal value makes up about 74% of it, and the value per share comes out at about S$1.80.

Keep the long-term growth rate modest. A company cannot grow faster than the economy around it for ever, or it would eventually become the economy, so analysts usually set long-term growth at or below long-run nominal economic growth, often near expected long-run inflation. The growth rate must also stay well below the discount rate. As it approaches the discount rate, the denominator shrinks towards zero and the value heads towards infinity, and a value like that signals a broken input.

Then check that year five looks like a business in a steady state. Growth and reinvestment are linked, because growing for ever requires ongoing reinvestment to support it. If the final forecast year has capital spending far below depreciation, the terminal value assumes growth without the investment to pay for it.

Calculating terminal value with an exit multiple

The exit multiple method assumes the business is sold at the end of the forecast at a multiple of its earnings. The multiple is usually enterprise value to EBITDA, taken from what similar companies trade at today.

First work out final-year EBITDA, which is operating profit plus depreciation. For Larkspur in FY10 that is about 69.5 + 30.9 = about 100.4. Marcus applied a made-up multiple of 7 times EBITDA, giving a terminal value of about 703 (7 x 100.4). Discounted to today, that is about 457. Enterprise value is about 603.4 (146.5 + 457), terminal value is about 76% of it, and the value per share is about S$1.94.

The method is simple and ties the value to real market prices. Its weakness is that it brings today's market pricing back into a method meant to value the business independently of the market, so if peers are expensive now, the exit multiple makes your DCF expensive too. Module 9, lesson 9.3, "Choose a peer group that is really comparable", shows how to find what similar companies trade at.

Using each method to test the other

The two methods are most useful as checks on each other. From the growth method, work out the implied multiple: terminal value divided by final-year EBITDA. For Larkspur, 634 / 100.4 is about 6.3 times EBITDA. Judge that against what similar companies trade at. If the growth method implied 15 times EBITDA for a cyclical parts maker, the growth rate or the margins would be too high.

From the exit multiple, work out the implied growth rate using the growth formula rearranged: (terminal value x discount rate - final cash flow) / (terminal value + final cash flow). Larkspur's 7 times EBITDA implies growth of about 2.6% a year for ever. Compare that with long-run inflation, which might be around 2%, and with long-run economic growth. A multiple that implied 5% growth for ever could not be defended.

Marcus judged the gap between S$1.80 and S$1.94 small enough to live with. Because the exit multiple implied about 2.6% growth for ever, which is on the high side, he chose the growth method's more cautious S$1.80 as his base case. When the two methods disagree widely, one of them is wrong, and the cross-check shows you which assumption to question.

For the activity, calculate your company's terminal value by both methods, then work out what share of total enterprise value each one makes up.

Calculate your company's terminal value both ways and note what share of total value each one makes up.

Course

Junxiong-WFG Organisation is an authorised representative of AIA Financial Advisers Private Limited (Reg. No. 201715016G).