Valuing banks and REITs, where a standard DCF breaks

You will be able to choose a valuation method for banks and REITs and explain why free cash flow does not fit them.

Marcus tried his Larkspur discounted cash flow (DCF) model on his local bank and gave up within ten minutes. When he tried the same method on his S-REIT, he hit the opposite problem.

A standard DCF based on free cash flow, the cash left from operations after capital spending, fails for both banks and REITs, for opposite reasons. At a bank, operating cash flow swings by billions from year to year as deposits come in and loans go out, and capital spending is tiny, a rounding error. A REIT pays out almost everything it earns, so there is little to forecast except the payout itself.

Why free cash flow breaks down for a bank

An industrial company borrows to fund its operations, and its debt sits apart from the business. At a bank, borrowing is the business itself. A bank takes deposits, which are debts it owes to customers, and lends them out at a higher rate, so debt is its raw material. Deposits, wholesale funding and loans all move with the bank's operations. You cannot draw a clear line between operating cash flow and financing cash flow, so free cash flow to the firm stops meaning anything for a bank.

So you value bank equity directly instead, from what shareholders receive or earn. You discount it at the cost of equity, the return shareholders require, rather than at WACC, the weighted average cost of capital that blends the cost of debt and equity.

Valuing Marcus's bank three ways

Say Marcus's bank has a book value of S$20 a share, a return on equity (ROE, yearly profit divided by book value) of 12%, a cost of equity of 9% and long-term growth of 3% (all example figures).

The dividend discount model, in its simplest version, sets value per share equal to next year's dividend divided by (cost of equity minus long-term dividend growth). It suits banks better than most companies for two reasons. Banks pay steady dividends, and regulators require banks to hold capital in proportion to their loans, which ties growth to retained profit.

Start with the retention ratio, which is growth divided by ROE: 3% / 12% = 25%, so the bank keeps a quarter of its profit. The payout ratio is 1 minus the retention ratio, which is 75%. Earnings per share are ROE times book value per share: 12% x S$20 = S$2.40. A 75% payout gives a dividend of S$1.80, and the value is S$1.80 / (9% minus 3%) = S$30.

Then rerun the model with the cost of equity one point lower and one point higher. At 8% the value is S$36. At 10% it is about S$25.70. Because the dividend is assumed to grow for ever, the answer is very sensitive to the cost of equity: a one-point change moves the value by roughly a fifth either way.

The excess return model values the bank as its book value plus the present value of the profits it earns above what shareholders require. Excess return per share is (ROE minus cost of equity) x book value per share. For Marcus's bank, 12% minus 9% is 3 points on S$20, which comes to S$0.60 a share, growing at 3%. Value that stream as excess return / (cost of equity minus growth): S$0.60 / 6% = S$10. Add book value and you get S$20 + S$10 = S$30.

That is the same answer as the dividend discount model, but it shows where the value comes from: S$20 of book value and S$10 from earning more than shareholders require. It also explains why bankers and analysts quote price to book so often, and why price to book misleads when used on its own. A bank whose ROE equals its cost of equity earns nothing above what shareholders require, so it is worth about book value, a price to book of 1. A bank whose ROE is above its cost of equity is worth more than book.

Justified price to book is (ROE minus growth) / (cost of equity minus growth). For Marcus's bank, 12% minus 3% is 9 points and 9% minus 3% is 6 points, which gives 1.5 times book. Multiply 1.5 by the S$20 book value and you get S$30 again.

Reading price to book next to ROE

Marcus's bank trades at S$32, which is 1.6 times book. If the bank can keep its ROE at 12% or more, that price is cheap. If ROE drifts down to 9%, the fair price to book falls to 1 and the value falls to S$20, which makes S$32 expensive. Price to book only means something when you read it next to ROE. The question you ask about any bank is whether it can keep earning its ROE through a credit cycle. Module 9, lesson 9.6, "Industry frameworks: banks, insurers, commodity producers and software", lists the measures that show this.

Valuing an S-REIT from distributions and NAV

S-REITs distribute most of their taxable income to unitholders, which lets them avoid tax at the REIT level. Dividend stocks and S-REITs, lesson 4.2, "The payout rule and tax transparency", explains how this works. Because a REIT retains so little, you have little to forecast except the payout. REIT growth comes mainly from rent increases, new acquisitions funded by new units or new debt, and changes in property values. Free cash flow to the firm still exists for a REIT in theory, but in practice two methods do most of the work: valuing the distributions, and comparing the price with net asset value (NAV), what the REIT's assets are worth minus its liabilities.

The steps here add only the valuation. Before you trust any distribution you discount, check that it is safe: gearing, interest cover, debt maturity profile, occupancy, rent reversions and weighted average lease expiry (WALE). Dividend stocks and S-REITs, module 5, "Read a REIT's numbers like a lender would", teaches each of these and gives you the scorecard to run first.

Distribution valuation uses the same formula as the bank dividend discount model: next distribution / (required return minus growth). Marcus's REIT pays S$0.12 a unit and trades at S$2.00, a yield of 6%. He expects distributions to grow 1% a year and wants a 7% return. The next distribution is 0.12 x 1.01, about S$0.121. Divide that by 7% minus 1%, which is 6%, and the value is about S$2.02. At a required return of 7.5% it is about S$1.86, and at 6.5% it is about S$2.20.

Price to NAV is the unit price divided by net asset value per unit, and NAV is built from property valuations. Dividend stocks and S-REITs, lesson 5.4, "NAV per unit and what price to NAV tells you", explains how. Marcus's REIT has a NAV of S$2.30 per unit, so at S$2.00 it trades at about 0.87 times NAV.

Use the two methods together. A REIT on a low price to NAV whose distributions do not support even the current price usually has a reason for its discount, and the module 5 scorecard is where you look for it.

When you value a real STI bank, take its latest dividend, book value and return on equity, then rerun the model at a cost of equity one point higher and one point lower.

Value one STI bank with a dividend discount model and one S-REIT on its distributions and price to NAV, then write one sentence for each explaining why free cash flow does not fit it.

Calculators for this lesson

Course

Junxiong-WFG Organisation is an authorised representative of AIA Financial Advisers Private Limited (Reg. No. 201715016G).