Compare renting with buying on the full yearly cost of each over the years you'll stay, not rent against the instalment.
[[versus Rent vs instalment | Full yearly cost | What it counts: Two monthly figures / Interest, fees, tax, lost earnings > B | Stay length: Ignored / Decided first > B]]
Buying looks S$495 a month cheaper, until you count what owning costs.
---
[[flow S$560,000 resale flat | S$420,000 HDB loan (75%), 25 years at 2.6% | S$1,905 a month]]
The flat, the S$2,400 rent and the S$40,000 renovation are made-up examples. 2.6% is HDB's loan rate to December 2026. One-off costs are split over the 10 years.
---
?^ Which costs more in a year? Rent at S$2,400 a month | 28800 | S$2,400 x 12 Loan interest in year one | 10777 | S$420,000 at 2.6% starts at S$910 a month and falls a little as the loan shrinks The whole instalment | 22860 | S$1,905 x 12, interest and repayment together Stamp duty, split over 10 years | 1140 | 1% of S$180,000 + 2% of S$180,000 + 3% of S$200,000 = S$11,400, divided by 10 Renovation, split over 10 years | 4000 | S$40,000 divided by 10 Service and conservancy charges | 960 | S$80 a month x 12, inside the usual S$21 to S$123 What the downpayment would have earned | 3500 | S$140,000 x 2.5%, the CPF OA rate Property tax, living in it yourself | 480 | Say an annual value of S$24,000: the first S$12,000 is tax-free, 4% on the other S$12,000 A S$200 rent rise at renewal | 2400 | S$200 x 12
---
[[bridge Interest 10777 | Stamp duty and renovation +5140 | Charges and property tax +1440 | Return given up +3500 | Owning, year one 20857 =]]
Rent is S$28,800. The other S$12,083 of the instalment repays the loan. Repairs, insurance and selling fees come on top.
---
| Renting, ___ years | Buying, ___ years | |---|---| | Rent | Stamp duty | | Rent rises | Legal, valuation fees | | Agent fees | Cash over valuation | | Moving costs | Renovation | | Deposit held | Loan interest | | | Tax and service charges | | | Fire and home protection cover | | | Repairs | | | Lost return on downpayment | | | Selling: agent, legal fees |
---
?? Same flat, but you expect to move after 3 years. What settles it? Stamp duty at S$3,800 a year still beats S$28,800 of rent + The MOP: you can't sell an HDB flat for 5 years Interest, since it's highest in the first few years => HDB owners must live in the flat for 5 years before selling, and can't rent the whole flat out before then. Check your stay against the MOP before you look at prices.
---
Once for 5 years, once for 15. If the answer flips, how long you'll stay is the real decision.
Leave out what the flat might sell for. Nobody can forecast it, so don't build your answer on a guess.
---
[[try rent-vs-buy | Run your own stay]]
In a notes app, write how many years you expect to stay, then list every cost of renting and of buying over those years, amounts left blank.
Junxiong-WFG Organisation is an authorised representative of AIA Financial Advisers Private Limited (Reg. No. 201715016G).