Lock-ins, clawbacks and the real cost of a package

Find the lock-in, clawback and after-lock-in rate in a loan package and price what each costs before comparing rates.

What leaving early costs

[[big S$6,000 | on S$400,000 still owed, if you repay or refinance inside the lock-in]]

Banks often charge around 1.5%, but terms vary by bank and package, so check your letter of offer. A rate 0.15 points lower saves you about S$600 a year.

---

Find the four costly lines

[[doc letter | Loan S$400,000 | 2.35% fixed, 3 years | Then SORA + 1.20% (1) | Lock-in 3 years, 1.5% penalty (2) | S$2,000 subsidy, clawback 3 years (3) | Prepay from S$10,000 (4) | 1: From year 4 | 2: Leaving inside it | 3: Refund if you leave | 4: Bonus rules | find 4]]

---

Say you still owe S$400,000. Each figure is a worked example on that loan. Is the next one more money or less?

?^ What's at stake on S$400,000? What a rate 0.15 points lower saves in a year | 600 | 0.15% x S$400,000 Repaying or refinancing inside the lock-in | 6000 | 1.5% x S$400,000 A S$2,000 legal subsidy taken back | 2000 | the subsidy, refunded in full One year on a rate 1 point higher after the lock-in | 4000 | 1% x S$400,000, a little less once you've repaid some A S$800 fee to reprice with the same bank | 800 | the fee, paid once Two years on that higher rate | 8000 | 1% x S$400,000 x 2, a little less as you repay Paying off an HDB loan early | 0 | HDB loans have no lock-in, so no penalty

---

The fixed years are the **cheap part**

A 0.15-point gap is about S$600 a year. A penalty or a year on a higher rate runs to thousands.

Count a subsidy only if you'll stay past its clawback.

If you might sell in the next few years, compare lock-ins before rates.

---

?? Say the lock-in is 2 years and the S$2,000 subsidy is clawed back within 3. You refinance in month 30. What do you owe? Nothing, as the lock-in is over + The S$2,000 refund, but no penalty The 1.5% penalty and the S$2,000 refund => Month 30 is past the lock-in, so no penalty. It's still inside the clawback, so the S$2,000 goes back.

---

On an HDB loan now?

It has no lock-in, so paying it off early costs S$0. A bank can take it over whenever the bank approves.

Once you move, you can't switch back to HDB.

---

[[try mortgage-prepayment-penalty | Price your package's exit costs]]

Take the letter of offer for one package, find its lock-in, penalty rate and clawback period, then run them through the calculator below with what you still owe.

Calculators for this lesson

Course

Junxiong-WFG Organisation is an authorised representative of AIA Financial Advisers Private Limited (Reg. No. 201715016G).