Compare an HDB loan and three bank packages by interest over the longest lock-in and over the full 25 years.
?? Two of these are true. Which one isn't? Once you leave an HDB loan for a bank, you can't go back + A fixed-rate package keeps the same rate for all 25 years of the loan Repaying a bank loan during its lock-in can cost about 1.5% of what's left => A fixed rate only lasts for the fixed period, and after that the rate floats. CPF says moving from an HDB loan to a bank is one-way, and an early repayment penalty is around 1.5% of the loan still owed.
---
| | Rate | Lock-in, years | |---|---|---| | HDB loan | 2.6% | None | | A | 2.50%, then SORA + 1% | 2 | | B | SORA + 0.3% | 2 | | C | 2.35%, then SORA + 1.2% | 3 |
SORA at 2.40%, 25-year loans, a S$2,000 legal subsidy on A. Cost all four over 3 years, the longest lock-in.
---
[[flow Balance at the start of the year | Instalment for the months left, at that year's rate | Interest that year | Balance carries over]]
A spreadsheet's PMT function works out the instalment. On A, S$1,794 a month rises to S$1,967 in year 3.
---
?^ Which costs more in interest? HDB loan, first 3 years | 29870 | S$400,000 at 2.6%, 36 instalments of S$1,814.68 Package C, first 3 years | 26960 | 2.35% fixed, instalments of S$1,764.40 Package B, first 3 years | 31040 | 2.70% while SORA stays at 2.40% Package A, first 3 years, after its S$2,000 subsidy | 30070 | S$32,070 of interest - S$2,000 Package C, all 25 years, SORA unchanged | 190210 | 3.60% from year 4 HDB loan, all 25 years | 144400 | S$1,814.68 x 300 = S$544,404, minus the S$400,000 borrowed Package B, all 25 years, SORA up a point from year 3 | 204440 | 3.70% from year 3 Package B, all 25 years, SORA unchanged | 150510 | 2.70% throughout
---
| | 3 years | 25 years | 25 years, SORA up a point | |---|---|---|---| | HDB loan | S$29,870 | S$144,400 | S$144,400 | | A | S$30,070 | S$184,090 | S$240,100 | | B | S$31,040 | S$150,510 | S$204,440 | | C | S$26,960 | S$190,210 | S$242,010 |
A is after its S$2,000 subsidy. The HDB rate tracks CPF, not SORA.
---
Over three years, the difference is S$29,870 - S$26,960 = S$2,910. Leaving HDB is one-way, and keeping that lead for 25 years means repricing or refinancing at every lock-in.
If you won't, measure the bank quotes against the HDB loan's S$144,400.
---
?> Where are you starting from? You're buying and can get an HDB loan => Fill in all four rows, and work out the HDB row over the full 25 years, since you can only leave it once. Your household income is above the HDB loan limit => An HDB loan needs an income of S$16,000 a month or less for families, or S$8,000 for singles, so compare the bank rows only. You already have a bank loan => You can't go back to an HDB loan, so leave that row out. Before your lock-in ends, put your bank's repricing offer beside two new quotes.
---
If you chose C, ask your bank for its repricing rate before year 3 ends, and get two new quotes.
If the repricing rate is more than 0.5 points above the best quote, switch once you've checked the clawback and the legal fees.
---
?# Your message to the bank Hi, I'm comparing home loans for {loan amount} over {how many} years. For {package name}, could you send the rate for each year of the lock-in, the rate after it, the lock-in penalty, and any subsidy with its clawback period?
Send the message above to two banks, and add each reply as a row in a spreadsheet next to the HDB loan at 2.6%.
Junxiong-WFG Organisation is an authorised representative of AIA Financial Advisers Private Limited (Reg. No. 201715016G).