Work out the break-even on switching

Work out the month a switch pays back its costs, and check that it falls inside the new lock-in.

?> Your lock-in ends next month, with S$400,000 left on the loan. Which do you take? Stay on the floating rate, 3.60% => It costs nothing today. It also pays about S$233 a month more interest than repricing would. Reprice with your bank: 2.90%, S$800 fee => The cheapest switch. Whether it's enough is what the next few cards check. Refinance elsewhere: 2.60%, S$3,000 in fees => The lowest rate. First, find out what it really costs.

---

Tap every cost of switching

[[doc letter | Refinancing quote | Loan S$400,000 at 2.60%, 2-year lock-in | Legal fees S$2,400 (1) | Valuation fee S$600 (2) | Old bank: subsidy clawback S$500 (3) | 1: Lawyer for the new loan | 2: The new bank's valuer | 3: You're 2 years into a 3-year clawback | find 3 | case Not a cost]]

---

What the lower rate saves

[[flow 3.60% down to 2.60%: 1 point | 1% of S$400,000 = S$4,000 a year | / 12 = about S$333 a month]]

A little less in practice, since the balance falls each month.

---

Cost divided by saving

[[sum The refinance costs S$3,500 and saves about S$333 a month against staying. In which month has it paid for itself? | 11 | 10 => S$333 x 10 is S$3,330. Still S$170 short. | => S$3,500 / S$333 = 10.5, so it's covered during month 11.]]

---

Beat repricing, not just staying

[[bridge Refinance costs 3500 | Repricing fee -800 | Extra cost 2700 =]]

Repricing is your real alternative. 2.90% to 2.60% saves S$100 a month on S$400,000. S$2,700 / S$100 = 27 months.

---

Does it pay back **inside the lock-in**?

[[timeline Month by month, 25 years left | Month 4 Repricing has paid for itself | Month 11 Refinance beats staying | Month 24 New lock-in ends | Month 28 Refinance beats repricing]]

Four months too late, and at month 24 you choose again. Reprice.

---

?? Now the other bank offers 2.30%, same S$3,500 costs and 2-year lock-in, on your S$400,000. Repricing is still 2.90% for S$800. Which? Reprice: S$2,700 extra is too much + Refinance: it pays back inside the lock-in Stay floating and wait for rates to fall further => 2.90% to 2.30% saves S$200 a month more than repricing. S$2,700 / S$200 = 13.5, so about month 14, well inside 24.

---

A subsidy can restart the clock

[[bridge Extra over repricing 2700 | New bank subsidy -2000 | Extra now 700 =]]

Say the new bank pays S$2,000 of your legal fees.

Leave inside its clawback period, though, and you repay it. Write that date beside the lock-in.

---

Still in a lock-in, or on HDB?

[[big S$6,000 | the penalty to leave inside a lock-in: around 1.5% of S$400,000]]

Usually, wait it out.

Refinance an HDB loan with a bank and you can't move back to an HDB loan later.

---

Paid back before the lock-in ends, or stay

If the saving can't cover the cost by then, the lower rate is the dearer deal.

---

[[try mortgage-refinancing | Run your own switch]]

Put your loan balance, both rates and every cost from the new bank's quote into the calculator below, and check that the break-even month lands before the new lock-in ends.

Calculators for this lesson

Course

Junxiong-WFG Organisation is an authorised representative of AIA Financial Advisers Private Limited (Reg. No. 201715016G).