Financial advice is a regulated act, not a sales pitch

Explain why a recommendation from a representative carries legal duties that a casual opinion does not.

If you work for a financial advisory firm or an insurer in Singapore, recommending a product to someone is regulated activity. It counts as advice even in an informal setting, and the rules on regulated advice shape the course of your career as a representative.

Picture a friend asking you over lunch which insurance plan to buy for their new baby. You know the products well, and you could send them a link before the coffee arrives. In most jobs that would be a helpful thing to do. In your job, naming a plan across the lunch table is giving financial advice, and the law has a view on how that should be done.

The law is the Financial Advisers Act (FAA), which sets up the regulation of financial advice in Singapore. Under the FAA, advising others on investment products and certain insurance products, for a fee or as part of a business, may only be done by licensed firms and their appointed representatives. MAS supervises the licensed firms, and the firms are responsible for the people they appoint. A representative is a person a licensed firm has appointed to give financial advice on its behalf. You are not licensed in your own right; you act under your firm's licence.

Becoming a representative starts when a licensed firm appoints you to give advice on its behalf. The firm checks that you are fit and proper and that you have passed the required exams, then notifies MAS. Once MAS is notified, your name appears on the MAS Register of Representatives. The register is public and anyone can search it. Clients do search it, and journalists search it when something goes wrong.

The required exams are the CMFAS modules (Capital Markets and Financial Advisory Services examinations). Which modules you need depends on the products you will advise on. A representative advising only on life insurance needs a different set of modules from one who also advises on collective investment schemes. Your firm tells you which modules apply to you, and the current list of CMFAS modules is on the IBF website.

In most sales jobs, the only test of a recommendation is whether the customer bought and stayed happy. Financial advice adds a second test, and it applies whether or not the client complains. The FAA requires a reasonable basis for every recommendation: before recommending anything, you have taken account of the client's objectives, financial situation and particular needs, and you can show it on paper. If you cannot show that reasoning on paper, the recommendation fails the test even if the client loves the product.

This changes the pace of a sales conversation. A strong seller in another industry moves quickly from the customer's problem to a product. A strong representative slows down at the start, because the questions you ask and the answers you record are the evidence that your advice was sound. The fact-find is the questioning and recording you do at the start of a meeting, and it forms that evidence. Treat it as the main part of the conversation, and avoid rushing through it as admin before you get to the product.

MAS sets out what it expects firms to deliver for customers in its Guidelines on Fair Dealing. The guidelines describe five outcomes, covering the firm's culture, suitable products, competent representatives giving quality advice, clear information, and fair handling of complaints. Three of the five depend directly on what you say and do in a meeting. You will work through each of the five outcomes in Module 2.

For representatives who already work this way, these rules do not make selling harder. They make it harder to last for those who do not. The risky behaviours are skipping the fact-find, selling whichever product has the best payout this quarter, and switching a client out of an old policy without a clear reason. An adviser who does these things may still close the sale. The case can still be sampled, the file may not hold up, and the cost shows up in pay, in reputation, and sometimes on the register itself.

Back at lunch, the right answer to your friend is to hold off on naming a product and offer to sit down properly. At that meeting, ask about their income, the cover they already have through work, their spouse's situation, and what they want for the child. Those answers cover their objectives, financial situation and particular needs. Record them as you go, because they are your evidence. Then recommend something you could defend to anyone who read the file.

Now search the MAS Register of Representatives for your own name if you are a representative, or for any adviser you have met. Note which firm they represent, what types of products they are notified for, and whether anything else is listed against them.

Look up yourself, or an adviser you know, on the MAS Register of Representatives. Write down the firm, the product types listed and any other entries.

Course

Junxiong-WFG Organisation is an authorised representative of AIA Financial Advisers Private Limited (Reg. No. 201715016G).