Explain how the balanced scorecard ties part of a representative's variable pay to the quality of their advice.
Daniel advises clients at a financial advisory firm, and his last quarter went well: sales far above target, and praise from his manager in front of the whole team. A few days later the firm's quality team writes to him. They sampled two of his cases, and one has a finding because the fact-find has no record of the client's existing cover, so his variable pay for the period will be affected. He had always taken it that pay in this line of work came down to how much you sell, and he now knows it does not come down to that alone.
A lot of sales roles calculate the variable part of pay from a single figure, the amount sold. Singapore's financial advice industry uses a different arrangement, the balanced scorecard framework. Representatives are assessed on non-sales measures as well as on sales, and what that assessment finds can change the variable pay a representative is given.
A pay system built on sales alone rewards the biggest seller whether the advice behind each sale was sound or not. Pay would then be at odds with the fair dealing outcomes you met in module 2. By tying part of your earnings to the quality of your advice and selling, the framework keeps quality and pay moving the same way. Each quarter, you're judged on two things: the business you wrote, and whether your files show it was written properly.
Reviewers don't read all your cases. They use sampling: a selection of your cases is pulled and checked against a set of non-sales measures. These come straight out of material in earlier modules. The checks cover whether the fact-find was done properly, whether the recommendation was suitable for the client and had a reasonable basis, whether the key features and risks of the product were disclosed, and whether the firm's other requirements were met. Lesson 5.2, "What reviewers look for in a sampled case", takes the reviewer's questions in turn.
When a reviewer identifies a fault in a sampled case, that is a finding, and it counts against you in the assessment. Your variable pay for the period can be reduced, depending on how serious the findings are and on your firm's policy. The missing record of existing cover in Daniel's file was this kind of fault.
Supervisors are assessed under the same framework, and part of their assessment depends on the quality of the representatives they supervise, which is one reason they take file quality seriously. Nobody tells you beforehand which cases will be sampled, so the only dependable habit is to write every file on the assumption that someone will read it.
Your supervisor or team leader is the fastest source to try before you turn to the formal documents. They review files and see findings across the whole team, so they know which faults keep recurring. Most are happy to be asked, since every finding you avoid is one less for them to deal with. Questions worth asking:
Which faults most often lead to findings in this firm? If you opened one of my files, what would you check first? Could you show me an anonymised finding and explain what would have prevented it?
Daniel went to his supervisor (also invented) once his finding had come through. She listed the three faults she comes across most: no record of existing cover, rationales that leave out alternatives, and disclosure records that carry only a signature. He copied all three onto the inside cover of the notebook he takes to client meetings.
Everything above describes the framework in outline. The detail sits in two places, and you need to read both.
MAS publishes documents on the balanced scorecard for financial advisory representatives. They describe how the framework is designed, the categories of non-sales measures and the relationship between assessments and pay. Look up the current version on the MAS website.
Your firm has its own policy on how it applies the framework, covering the measures it checks, the way it samples cases, how it grades findings and how each grade affects pay. This policy is where you see what a finding would actually cost you. Your supervisor or the compliance team can give you a copy.
Take the specific measures, grades and pay effects from those documents, and not from a colleague's summary, a training slide or a course, this one included. The details change over time and vary from firm to firm, and a small error in your understanding could lead you to misjudge your own position. For that reason the course does not set them out.
Most representatives learn how the balanced scorecard affects their pay only after they get a finding, as Daniel did. You can learn it in advance, and knowing the cost of a finding gives you a clear reason to take the next three lessons seriously.
For the activity below, get your firm's policy and write a plain-words summary of what happens to your variable pay when a sampled case has a finding at each level your firm uses.
Ask your firm for its current balanced scorecard policy, then write a short note on how a finding would affect your pay.
Junxiong-WFG Organisation is an authorised representative of AIA Financial Advisers Private Limited (Reg. No. 201715016G).