Run an edit on a real piece

You will edit a piece with a checklist, a readability tool and a test reader, and compare before and after.

Open the piece you plan to edit, duplicate the file, and name the copy so you know it is the "before" version. Do this before you touch a single word. Good candidates are the blog post you wrote in Lesson 6.4 or the landing page from Lesson 5.4. Choose whichever one a real customer is about to read, so whatever you improve gets used right away. Set aside about 30 minutes for the full exercise. At the end you'll compare your edited draft against the saved copy.

Editing by feel is hard because you read your own draft with knowledge the reader lacks. You know what each sentence was meant to say, so every sentence seems clear to you. Read the same page enough times and your eyes slide over it without registering the words. To get around that, you'll put the piece through three checks that don't rely on your sense of what is clear: a checklist, readability software, and a person who has never read it. Each of the three picks up problems the other two miss.

Five checklist items, one at a time

Every item comes from something taught earlier in the course. Work on one item, fix whatever it turns up, and only then go on to the next.

Answer early: put the main point or answer in the opening paragraph or at the top of the page (Lessons 5.1 and 6.2). One idea per paragraph: give each paragraph a single point, and split any paragraph that drifts to a new subject partway through. Average sentence length: measure it, decide on a target, and examine any sentence that runs well over that target. Active voice: make each sentence show who does what, and rewrite passive sentences where the doer matters (Lesson 7.1). Plain words: replace vague or inflated words with specific ones your reader would actually use (Lesson 7.2).

The sentence length item needs a number. Your average sentence length comes from ten sentences picked from different parts of the piece: count the words in each, add the ten counts together, and divide by ten. For a target, the lessons in this course aim for a median sentence under 18 words.

Priya, who is taking the course, used her blog post on whether a child needs tuition (her figures throughout are an example). She sampled sentences of 14, 22, 9, 31, 17, 12, 26, 15, 8 and 19 words. The total was 173, so her average was 173 / 10 = 17.3 words, close to the target she had set. Two sentences sat well above it, at 31 and 26 words. She broke the 31-word sentence into two and trimmed the 26-word one to 18 words.

Deciding which software flags to act on

A readability tool is software that reads your piece and highlights sentences that may be hard to follow. Hemingway Editor is one; it marks long and complex sentences, passive voice and adverbs. Most word processors include their own checks too, such as grammar suggestions and readability statistics, which you can switch on in settings. Either paste the piece into a tool or turn those checks on, then write down what gets highlighted.

Treat each highlight as a reason to read that sentence again and nothing more. The software changes nothing by itself. It has no idea who your reader is or what you mean; all it does is count words and recognise patterns. Keep this rule in mind: tools point, you decide.

Some of what gets flagged is a genuine problem and some is fine as written. A long sentence that lists things in a natural order can read easily. When it doesn't matter who carried out an action, the passive can work better than the active, as in "The centre was founded in 2016". A short sentence the tool approves of may also come across as too blunt in context. Go through the highlights one by one and ask whether a reader would trip over that sentence. Rewrite it if they would, and leave it alone if they wouldn't.

Out of 11 sentences the tool flagged in Priya's post, she rewrote 7 and kept 4 as they were. One of the four was a list of things to bring to a trial lesson. The tool scored it "very hard to read", yet every parent who read it understood it immediately.

Avoid editing just to raise the score. A piece that reaches a perfect score but no longer says what it meant is worse than a piece that keeps a few long sentences that do their job.

Checking what a first-time reader takes away

Write down, in one sentence, what you think the piece says. Do this before anyone else sees it, so you have your own version to hold their answer against.

Next, find a test reader who belongs to your target group and hasn't read the piece. Ask them to read it and sum it up in one sentence, and record what they say exactly as they say it. Then set their sentence next to yours. A match means the piece is clear. If theirs is close but leaves something out, that part needs more weight or needs to appear sooner. If theirs describes something else altogether, the structure is the problem, and you should return to the first pass from Lesson 7.1.

Priya wrote her own summary as: "Practice at home is enough if your child understands the method, and tuition helps if they don't." Her reader said: "You can check at home whether your kid needs tuition by asking them to explain a question." Priya decided the two were close. The reader's version showed her that the at-home check, placed at the end of the post, was the part that stuck. She added a short version of that check to the opening paragraph.

Keeping a record of the changes

Count the words in the "before" copy and in the edited piece, and write down the difference. Priya's post had gone through three rounds of editing before she started this exercise, and it still dropped from 905 words to 870.

Alongside the word counts, keep your completed checklist, the number of sentences the tool flagged with how many you changed, and the reader's summary written next to yours. Priya got more from the reader's summary than from the word count, since it told her what the post had actually taught.

For your own activity, choose a piece a real customer will read soon so the work goes straight into use, and save the "before" version first. The comparison is half of what you learn from the exercise.

Edit one piece with the checklist and a readability tool, then record the before and after word count and your test reader's one-sentence summary.

Course

Junxiong-WFG Organisation is an authorised representative of AIA Financial Advisers Private Limited (Reg. No. 201715016G).