Avoid whether-or-not decisions by coming up with more options.
Pick up a pen and write down one decision you keep putting off. Use the same words that run through your head when it comes up, however awkward they look on the page.
Check the shape of that sentence. A decision worded as "should I ... or not" leaves you two moves: go ahead, or don't. A yes-or-no question can only return a yes or a no. If neither answer appeals, people tend to stall, or they settle on whichever option is least painful at that moment. In many cases the question is the problem, and no answer to it will feel right.
In their book "Decisive", Chip and Dan Heath call this narrow framing: defining a decision too tightly, usually as a yes-or-no choice about one option. At work you hear it in questions such as "Should we hire a new person or not?", "Should I take this job offer or not?" and "Should we launch the product in March or not?" (the March date is an invented example). Each one puts exactly two options on the table and keeps every other route to the real goal out of sight.
You met a close relative of this in Lesson 2.1, "Attacking the person, the straw man and the false choice". In a false dilemma, or false choice, another person gives you two options and acts as if no others exist. Narrow framing is the personal version. You build the two options yourself through the way you word the question in your own head.
The Heaths' advice is to treat any whether-or-not decision as a signal to go and find more options before you answer it.
Hafiz (an invented example) works in operations. He has a young child, and his job already uses up his evenings. He has spent three months going back and forth on a part-time MBA and still has not decided. He has the brochure, a rough idea of the fees, and a colleague who tells him the MBA changed her career.
Start by writing down the goal behind the question. For Hafiz, the likely goal is to move out of operations into a more senior general management role within the next few years. The MBA is one route to that. With the goal on paper, he has something to measure every other route against.
The first question comes from opportunity cost: what else could the same money or time do? Hafiz notes the rough cost of the MBA over two years, in fees and in evenings. Then he asks what that money and time could do for his goal if he spent it another way. His list:
a shorter executive course in general management a certification in finance for non-finance managers, which covers a gap his boss has mentioned a stretch role in the company managing a second function, which costs no fees and gives exactly the experience he needs a mentor who holds a senior role SkillsFuture funding for some courses if he is eligible (the current amounts and rules are on the SkillsFuture website)
Several of these can be combined. The decision then becomes which combination brings him closest to the goal at the lowest cost. The same question works on team decisions. "Should we buy this software?" turns into "What else could this budget do about the problem the software is supposed to fix?" Answers might include a change to the process, a part-time hire, or a cheaper tool that handles most of the work.
The second question is the Heaths' vanishing options test. Imagine that every option you are weighing has disappeared, and ask yourself what you would do. Removing the familiar two pushes you to search for new routes. Hafiz tries it: if he could neither do the MBA nor stay in his current role, how would he get to general management? He comes up with two answers he had not thought of. He could ask his boss plainly what it would take. He could also look at operations roles in larger companies that have a clear route into general management.
A team can run the same test in a meeting. Someone asks what the team would do if the vendor being discussed went out of business tomorrow. The replies often include an option better than the one already on the table.
Once you have more options, you often don't have to choose between all of them in one go. The Heaths suggest checking your assumptions with small experiments before you commit to anything large. Their informal word for this is ooching, which means stepping a little way into a decision to see what happens. A good test is cheap, quick and reversible. It gives you real information, so you stop going back and forth.
Hafiz has a few he could try. He could sit in on one MBA class. He could take one short module before he enrols. He could ask to lead a cross-functional project for three months and find out whether general management suits him. A small trial like this is one of the best ways to turn a one-way door into a series of two-way doors, so you only commit fully once you know more. Lesson 6.1, "One-way doors and two-way doors", explains the difference.
Hafiz spends about an hour with a notebook and ends up with six options where he had two. He decides to ask for the stretch role and do a short finance course this year. He will come back to the MBA in eighteen months, when he has real experience to weigh it against.
The method has six steps. Notice the whether-or-not frame and take it as a signal. Name the real goal behind the question. Ask what else the same money or time could do for that goal. Run the vanishing options test and add anything it turns up. Pick the mix of options that gets closest to the goal for the least cost. Then ooch: try something cheap, quick and reversible before any large commitment.
You probably have a yes-or-no question of your own that has been going round in your head. Bring it to the activity below, where you will widen it before you choose.
Pick one yes-or-no decision in front of you and write down at least four other options before you choose.
Junxiong-WFG Organisation is an authorised representative of AIA Financial Advisers Private Limited (Reg. No. 201715016G).