When the average is not enough

You will be able to spot choices where a bad outcome would cost too much to accept, whatever the expected value.

Siti has just learned about expected value in lesson 7.2. A friend asks her to invest her entire savings of S$40,000 (an example figure) in a business opportunity he is sure about.

He tells her she will double her money within a year, to S$80,000, and puts the chance of success at 90 percent. Siti works out the expected value: 90 percent of S$80,000 is S$72,000, which is more than the S$40,000 she has now. On average, it is a great bet. She still feels it is a terrible idea, and her instinct is right. Expected value tells you only about the average, and some decisions turn on what happens if things go badly.

Siti's one chance in ten

By her friend's own numbers, the chance that the business fails and Siti loses all her savings is 10 percent. That is one time in ten, and a 1 in 10 chance is not rare. If it happens, she has no emergency fund and her plans for a home are delayed. If something else went wrong at the same time, she could end up in debt.

Why people buy insurance with a negative expected value

Insurance runs on the same reasoning. Take a made-up policy with a premium of S$300 a year, covering an event that has a 1 in 1,000 chance of costing S$100,000. The expected loss is the size of the loss multiplied by its probability: S$100,000 divided by 1,000, or S$100 a year. You pay S$300 to cover an expected loss of S$100, so the expected value of the insurance is minus S$200 a year.

Insurance has a negative expected value on average because the premiums have to cover the insurer's payouts, its costs and its profit. Across all customers, people pay in more than they get back. Judged on expected value alone, nobody would ever buy insurance.

People are often right to buy it anyway, because a large loss may be one they could not recover from: years of savings gone, debt, a home at risk. Insurance swaps a small certain loss for protection against a large loss that would take years to repair. A decision can be sound even when its expected value is negative. Which risks are worth insuring, and how, is a question for a finance course and a qualified adviser. The part that applies to Siti is the reasoning: when an outcome would be ruinous, avoiding it can be worth more than the average suggests.

Ruin and why the average cannot reach you

Ruin is a loss you cannot recover from and try again after. An ordinary loss hurts, and then you carry on and make the next decision. Ruin takes you out of the game. Expected value assumes you get to play many times so the average can work out. If one bad outcome takes you out, you never reach the average.

The rule is to avoid any bet where the worst case would ruin you, however good the average looks.

What counts as ruin depends on the person. Losing S$40,000 can be painful but survivable for someone with other savings and a steady income, and it can be everything for someone like Siti, whose whole safety net it is. The same bet can be reasonable for one person and reckless for another.

Small repeated bets and one big draw

Take a made-up bet where you win S$100 with a 60 percent chance and lose S$100 with a 40 percent chance. Its expected value is S$20 per bet. If you make it once, you have a 40 percent chance of losing. If you make it a hundred times at S$100 each, your expected total is S$2,000, and the chance of ending up behind after a hundred bets is under 2 percent. The more times you repeat a positive expected value bet at a size you can afford, the more reliably your results move towards the average.

Work offers plenty of these small, repeated positive expected value decisions: running many small experiments, sending many job applications, pitching to many clients. Any single one can fail, but across dozens the average shows through, and they tend to pay off over time. One large all-or-nothing bet gets no such protection, because you get only one draw.

A way out of a risky big bet is to break it into smaller ones. Put in an amount you can afford to lose, and add more only if it proves itself. If Siti believed in the business, she could invest an affordable amount now and more later once it had shown results. In the end she tells her friend she will not put in her savings, and that if he gets the business running she might put in a small amount she could afford to lose.

The worst case changes decisions at work too. A project with a high expected return but a small chance of losing your biggest client may not be worth it. A career move with a better average outcome but a real chance of leaving you without income for a year needs a savings buffer before you make it. Ruinous outcomes are usually one-way doors, and lesson 6.1, One-way doors and two-way doors, gives the same instinct from a different angle.

Questions to ask after the calculation

Expected value is still the first step. After you have it, look at the bad case before you decide:

Calculate the expected value of the decision. Ask what happens if you are wrong, in the bad case rather than on average. Ask whether you could recover from it. Ask how long recovery would take. Ask who else it would affect. If the worst case would ruin you, do not take the bet, however good the average looks. Where possible, break a big bet into smaller ones you can afford to lose, and add more only if it proves itself.

Written down, your answers to those questions give you a record to return to when the choice comes up for real. If your savings or income change before then, you can check the worst case again and see whether it has moved from ruinous to survivable.

Take one financial or career choice and write down its expected value, its worst case and whether you could recover from that worst case.

Course

Junxiong-WFG Organisation is an authorised representative of AIA Financial Advisers Private Limited (Reg. No. 201715016G).