Name the main MAS consumer protection measures for retail customers of licensed exchanges.
A crypto exchange licensed by MAS, the Monetary Authority of Singapore, must treat retail customers in specific, set ways. It must keep your tokens apart from its own assets and hold them on trust for you, check that you understand the risks before you trade, and it may not reward you for trading, lend you money to trade, or lend out or stake your tokens.
Darren signs up with a MAS-licensed exchange. The app will not let them buy anything until they answer questions about how crypto works and what can go wrong. A friend of Darren's joins an overseas app and gets S$50 of free tokens (an example figure) just for registering, and Darren gets nothing. Later, Darren wants their bitcoin to earn a yield, and the licensed app says it does not offer this to customers like them. Each of these annoyances comes from a MAS rule, and MAS brought in each rule on purpose in response to the crypto losses of 2022.
Of all these rules, segregation is the most important. Segregation means a licensed provider keeps retail customers' tokens separate from the firm's own assets. Besides segregating tokens, the provider must hold customer tokens on trust, keep proper records, and reconcile its holdings regularly. To reconcile holdings is to check that what the firm actually holds matches what it owes customers.
A trust is a legal arrangement in which one party holds property for the benefit of another party. In Darren's case, the exchange controls the keys, but the bitcoin in Darren's account is meant to remain Darren's property. If the exchange collapses, its creditors should not be able to treat that bitcoin as firm money to be divided among them. Lesson 5.2, "FTX: customer money that was not where it should be", shows what happens when a firm mixes customer assets with its own, and it is worth going back to it now.
Segregation makes it easier to get your tokens back if something goes wrong. It does not make recovery instant or certain, and Lesson 3.3 covers the gap between recovery being easier and recovery being instant or certain.
Before a retail customer can trade, a licensed provider must assess whether that customer understands the risks of digital payment tokens. The usual questions cover how far prices can swing, the chance of losing all your money, and the fact that a confirmed transfer cannot be reversed.
If you already know this material, the questions may feel patronising. They are aimed at people who do not know it. An app that lets anyone trade after a few taps makes money from people who may not understand what they are buying, and the risk check adds a delay to that path.
Three restrictions belong together: no trading incentives, no lending or margin, and no lending or staking of customer tokens. Each one blocks a way people ended up taking on more risk than they understood.
First, retail customers may not be offered incentives to trade. This covers free tokens for signing up, crypto referral bonuses, and other rewards for trading more. The S$50 Darren's friend received is the kind of reward a licensed provider may not offer a retail customer.
Second, a licensed provider may not lend retail customers money to buy tokens or let them trade on margin, which means trading with money borrowed from the provider. Borrowing to buy an asset whose price can halve within a month (an illustration of how far prices can fall, not a specific data point) can turn a painful loss into a debt you still have to repay after the tokens are gone.
Third, a licensed provider may not lend out or stake retail customers' tokens. You saw in Lesson 2.1, "Ethereum runs programs, and ether pays for them", that yield on deposited crypto usually comes from lending the crypto to someone else or locking it up to stake it. Lending out customers' coins is what brought down the platforms covered in Lesson 5.3, "Celsius, Hodlnaut and Zipmex: yield from lending your coins". MAS responded by stopping licensed firms from doing this with retail customers' tokens, and this ban is why Darren's app turned down their request for yield.
All of these protections apply to retail customers only. Under Singapore law, people who qualify as accredited investors or institutional investors are treated differently, and some providers offer them services that retail customers cannot buy. If an app offers you any of the following, find out whether you have been classed as something other than a retail customer, such as an accredited or institutional investor, and whether you agreed to that classification:
a sign-up reward a loan margin trading yield from lending or staking your tokens
Compared with some other cities, Singapore has few crypto ads in MRT stations, at bus stops or on billboards, and the reason is MAS. Its guidelines discourage crypto service providers from marketing to the general public in Singapore, and they name two things to avoid: advertisements in public places and payments to social media influencers. Providers are expected to limit promotion to their own websites, their own apps and their official social media accounts. MAS's view is that crypto is unsuitable for the general public, so firms should not target people who were not already looking for them. If a crypto firm reaches you in Singapore through a public billboard or a paid influencer, ask why it is not following guidelines that licensed firms are expected to follow.
MAS introduced these measures in several stages and has changed some details since, so read the exact wording and the dates the rules took effect at the source rather than relying on a summary. The MAS website has a consumer page on digital payment tokens, and MAS also publishes its guidelines and its responses to consultations there. Find those pages and read the exact wording of each rule and the date it took effect. As you read them, take one measure at a time and ask whether it applies to you as a retail customer, and what it would mean for your account if a firm broke it.
Open the current MAS page on consumer protection for digital payment tokens. List each measure that applies to you as a retail customer.
Junxiong-WFG Organisation is an authorised representative of AIA Financial Advisers Private Limited (Reg. No. 201715016G).