In-house, agency or freelance

You will be able to compare in-house, agency and freelance marketing work by variety, depth, pay structure and risk.

Three people finished a marketing diploma together. Two years later they meet for dinner. Wei Jie works in-house at a mid-sized furniture retailer and knows its customers better than anyone else in the company. Aisha works at a digital agency and has run campaigns for a bank, a bubble tea chain and a property developer, sometimes in the same week. Ravi went freelance after a year and now writes websites and emails for six small businesses from home.

Each of them is sure they made the right choice, and each of them has days when they envy the other two. They are describing the three main ways to work in marketing. None of them is better in general. They suit different people, and the same person at different stages of a career.

In-house: deep on one business

An in-house marketer works for the business whose products they market. Wei Jie's employer sells furniture, and every campaign, report and meeting is about furniture and the people who buy it.

The strength is depth. Over time, you learn the customers, the products, the sales figures and the history of what was tried before. You see the results of your work over months and years, not just at the end of a campaign. You sit near sales, operations and product, so you understand why the business makes the decisions it does. Much of what this course covers, from the journey map to the 90-day review, is work an in-house marketer does every quarter for the same business.

The weakness is slower variety. You may work on the same product and customer for years, and the skills you build are shaped by one company's channels and tools. In a small company you might be the only marketer, with nobody nearby to learn from.

Agency: many clients, fast learning

An agency sells marketing services to other businesses. Aisha works on several client accounts at once, and the agency charges those clients for her time.

The strength is variety and speed of learning. In a year at an agency, you might see more industries, channels and problems than in several years in-house. You work alongside specialists in other roles, so there is usually someone to learn from. Many marketers spend their early years at an agency for exactly this reason.

The trade-off is pace and pressure. Deadlines are set by clients, and several clients can want things at the same time. Many agencies track billable hours, the time staff spend on work the agency can charge a client for, so your time is counted closely. You also see less of the long-term result. A campaign ends, the client moves on, and you rarely learn what happened to their business a year later.

Freelance: control, and everything that comes with it

A freelancer works for themselves and sells their services directly to clients. Ravi chooses which businesses he works with, sets his own rates and decides his own hours.

That control is real, and it comes with jobs nobody else does for you. You find your own clients, which means you do sales as well as marketing. You write proposals, send invoices, chase late payments and keep records for tax. Income can vary a lot from month to month.

In Singapore, being self-employed also changes how CPF works. As an employee, you and your employer both contribute to CPF each month. As a self-employed person, there is no employer contribution, and if your net trade income is above a set level you must make MediSave contributions yourself. The thresholds and rates change, so check the current rules on the CPF Board website before you go freelance, and set aside money for MediSave and income tax as you earn. The course Self-employed and freelance: money with irregular income covers the money side in full.

Pay, and why the first choice isn't permanent

Pay structures differ too. In-house and agency roles usually pay a monthly salary, sometimes with a bonus. Freelancers set their own rates by project, by day or by monthly retainer. Pay varies widely by role, seniority and company, so don't rely on a figure you heard from a friend. Look at the salary ranges listed in real ads on MyCareersFuture, and at the annual salary guides that recruitment firms publish for Singapore.

Many marketers move between all three over a career. A common path is to start at an agency to learn fast, move in-house to go deep, and freelance later once you have skills and contacts that clients will pay for. Others start in-house at a small business, which forces them to do everything, then specialise at an agency. Some freelance for a while between full-time roles.

So the choice you make now is the right choice for now. Ask what you need most at this stage: steady income and depth, fast learning and variety, or control over your clients and time. Then ask what would make you switch later.

Wei Jie, Aisha and Ravi each had an answer to that second question. Wei Jie would move to an agency if he stopped learning. Aisha would go in-house if she wanted to see a business grow over years. Ravi would take a full-time job if a client offered one he cared about.

In the activity below you will write your own version. Be specific about the reasons. "More money" or "more freedom" is a start, but the reason that would actually move you is usually more particular than that.

Write which of the three suits you now and one reason each for the other two that might make you switch later.

Course

Junxiong-WFG Organisation is an authorised representative of AIA Financial Advisers Private Limited (Reg. No. 201715016G).