Judge whether a lead magnet idea is specific and useful enough that a stranger would give you an email address for it.
Priya runs a maths tuition centre in Tampines. The "Join our mailing list" box on the centre's website brought in a handful of addresses a year.
Module 1 got you as far as knowing who you are allowed to email and having a consent line on your form. What comes next is giving people a reason to fill that form in.
Most small business websites have a "Subscribe to our newsletter" box in the footer, and it collects almost nobody. Moving it higher up the page rarely helps, because the weak part is what the box offers. Very few people want extra email for its own sake. Plenty of people will hand over an address in return for an answer to a problem they are dealing with today.
Priya took the old box down and put up a one-page checklist instead: "The P5 maths heuristics, with one worked example each", aimed at parents who want to help at home. Parents searching for help with exactly that topic landed on the page, and far more of them signed up than the old box had ever managed. They could open the checklist and use it at that night's homework session, where the old box had offered only a vague promise of more email.
That checklist is a lead magnet: something useful you give away in exchange for an email address. Common formats are a checklist, a template, a short guide, a calculator, a sample, or a short course sent by email over a few days. The format you choose matters less than the deal itself. Your visitor gets something they want now, and you get permission to keep in touch.
Good lead magnets are small and deal with one specific problem the buyer has at the moment. Don't try to pack in everything you know about your subject.
Mei Ling bakes from home in Punggol. Mei Ling's first idea was "The complete guide to celebration cakes". The title sounds generous, but the content would be vague, writing it would take weeks, and a visitor could not tell what they would actually receive. A tighter version was "How far ahead to order a custom cake for every kind of party, on one page". A parent with a birthday coming up in six weeks can see straight away whether this is for them, and can use it in two minutes.
The narrow version does better for three reasons. A visitor can judge in a moment whether it fits their situation. They can put it to use quickly, so they get the value while they still remember who sent it. And it is small enough for you to finish making.
You will attract whoever wants the free thing. If you give away something unrelated to your business, you end up with a list of people who are never going to buy.
A free printable family timetable would bring Priya lots of signups, yet many of those people would have no children in upper primary and no reason ever to pay for tuition. The heuristics checklist draws parents of P5 and P6 children who are already doing maths with them at home, and some of those parents may book a trial class later.
To check direction, complete this sentence: "Someone who found this useful would probably also want..." When the sentence ends with what you sell, the idea is pointing the right way. For Mei Ling's ordering guide, it ends with "a custom cake for that party". A generic recipe ebook would fail the check, since it would pull in home bakers, the group least likely to order a cake from Mei Ling.
Shops most often use a discount, something like "Ten percent off your first order" (an example figure). It works because anyone about to buy finds it useful on the spot.
The drawback is what subscribers learn from it: your emails are where the discounts come from. Many will hold off on their next purchase until another discount turns up, and some will sign up again with a second address to get the code twice. Once every email you send is an offer, your list has turned into a coupon channel, and selling at full price gets harder.
A discount can still be a sound choice for a shop whose customers come back to buy often. If you choose one, do it knowing the trade-off, and plan the welcome emails in Module 4 so they give people a reason to stay that isn't another code.
Most people's first idea is too broad or too far from what they sell. You can get around this by writing several ideas and comparing them. Give each idea a score from 1 to 5 on each of these:
how useful it is to the buyer this week how fast they can start using it once it arrives how directly it leads to what you sell
Add up the three numbers for each idea, compare the totals, and pick the highest. Your scores will be rough judgements, and that is fine. Scoring makes you weigh the ideas against each other so you don't settle on whichever one came to mind first. You can run the direction sentence from earlier at the same time.
Mei Ling scored three ideas, in the order usefulness, speed to use, then link to what Mei Ling sells. The complete guide to celebration cakes got 3, 1 and 4, for a total of 8. The ordering timeline got 4, 5 and 5, for 14. The recipe ebook got 3, 3 and 1, for 7. The ordering timeline came out well ahead, and it was also the quickest of the three to make.
In the activity below you will write five ideas for your own business, score each one on usefulness, speed to use and link to what you sell, and pick the one you will build in lesson 2.4.
Write down five lead magnet ideas for your business. Score each from 1 to 5 on usefulness, speed to use and link to what you sell, then pick the one with the top score.
Junxiong-WFG Organisation is an authorised representative of AIA Financial Advisers Private Limited (Reg. No. 201715016G).