Lump sum vs DCA calculator

By MoneyBees

Compare investing a sum all at once with spreading it over monthly buys (dollar cost averaging), on a price path you set: a steady rise, a fall that recovers while you buy, or a fall that lasts. See what each ends at, the units you buy, and when DCA comes out ahead.

Calculator

Your money and the market path

S$
months
years
% a year
% a year

Lump sum ends at

$80,294

all $60,000 in on day one

DCA ends at

$78,895

12 buys of about $5,000

Lump sum ahead by

$1,398

after 5 years

Your monthly buys cost 1.027 a unit on average, against an average price of 1.027 over those months. Buying a fixed amount gets you more units when the price is low, so your cost sits below the average price.

When prices only rise, every month you wait you buy at a higher price. The lump sum has more time in the market and ends ahead, even after the $548 your waiting cash earned.

Save my results

Leave your email and we'll save this scenario so a MoneyBees adviser can follow up.

Or book a free chat if you'd rather talk it through.

The same plan on each path

Price pathLump sumDCADCA vs lump sum
Steady rise$80,294$78,895-$1,398
Falls, recovers while you buy$80,294$88,030+$7,737
Falls while you buy, recovers later$80,294$87,147+$6,853

Every path ends on the same 6% a year trend, so the lump sum ends at the same value on each. The fall is 20% at its lowest.

Your monthly buys

MonthPriceUnits boughtPaid
11.0005000.0$5,000
31.0104968.0$5,017
51.0204936.3$5,033
71.0304904.8$5,050
91.0404873.4$5,066
111.0504842.3$5,083
121.0554826.8$5,092

The price starts at 1.000. Each month you invest an equal share of the cash still waiting, interest included.

Worked example

You have S$1,200 and a flat market. You put it all in at 1.00 and get 1,200 units. Or you buy S$600 now at 1.00 (600 units) and S$600 next month, after the price halves to 0.50 (1,200 units).

When the price is back at 1.00, the lump sum is worth S$1,200 and the DCA plan S$1,800. Had the price risen instead, the lump sum would have won. DCA pays off only when prices fall while you are still buying.

How to read this

Markets have risen more often than they have fallen, so a lump sum usually ends ahead when you already hold the cash. DCA lowers the regret of putting everything in just before a fall. It suits money you earn month by month, such as part of your salary.

This page uses the path you set, not past market data, and does not forecast. Fees per buy are left out. Check them with the brokerage fee calculator, since many small buys can cost more. MoneyBees names no fund and does not recommend one.

Frequently asked questions

What is dollar cost averaging?

Investing a fixed amount at regular intervals, such as every month, whatever the price. You buy more units when the price is low and fewer when it is high.

Is lump sum better than DCA?

When prices rise steadily, a lump sum ends ahead because all your money is in the market for longer. DCA ends ahead only when prices fall while you are still buying. Nobody knows in advance which will happen.

Why does DCA give a lower average cost than the average price?

A fixed amount buys more units at low prices and fewer at high prices, so the cheap months count for more. Your cost per unit sits below the simple average of the prices you bought at.

Does DCA reduce risk?

It reduces the risk of putting everything in just before a fall, and the regret that comes with it. It does not reduce the risk of the investment itself once all your money is in.

What should I do with the cash while I spread out my buys?

Keep it somewhere safe that pays interest, such as a savings account, fixed deposit or Treasury bills. Enter that rate to see how much it narrows the gap.

Does this calculator use past market returns?

No. It uses the return and the size of fall you enter, so you can see how each path plays out. It does not forecast markets.

Do fees change the answer?

Yes. Twelve small buys can cost more in brokerage than one large one, especially with a minimum fee per trade. Some regular savings plans charge a flat fee per buy instead.

Keep exploring

These calculators provide general estimates for educational purposes only and are not personalised financial advice. Results may rely on rates and rules that change over time, so verify against official sources (IRAS, CPF Board, HDB, MAS) or consult a licensed financial adviser before making decisions.

Junxiong-WFG Organisation is an authorised representative of AIA Financial Advisers Private Limited (Reg. No. 201715016G).